- FAQ
- Login
- Register
- Call Workpermit.com for a paid service +44 (0)344-991-9222
ESC
Welcome to immigrationboards.com!
Moderators: Casa, archigabe, CR001, push, JAJ, ca.funke, Amber, zimba, vinny, Obie, EUsmileWEallsmile, batleykhan, meself2, geriatrix, John, ChetanOjha
As a non-EEA national if you were on your own you would need a Tier 4 visa to study.afairbairn wrote:Please excuse me if this post is in the wrong place, I was not quite sure where it fit.
I am currently in the UK and have been since July. I am a U.S. citizen and entered the UK with my wife who is a German citizen exercising her treaty rights.
I have an unconditional offer at a University here, and ignorantly, assumed that I could start without a Visa due to my wife being an EU citizen. I now find, one week prior to the start of courses, that I am unable to register for classes because I do not have any sort of visa.
The international student assistance office recommended that I apply for an EEA (FM) residence permit. I have done so and it arrived at the Home Office today.
I have essentially two questions.
First, is there any possibility that I can study without any visa etc.? I have looked for any law, regulation, loophole etc, but have been unable to find anything.
Second, I, as stated above, applied for an EEA (FM) residence permit, however the processing time is 6 months. I anticipate receiving a COA in the next week, hopefully not longer. Is it possible to study if I just have a COA, with right to work or otherwise?
If I should provide any more information I would be happy to do so.
Thank you in advance for your assistance and suggestions,
Andrew
*I forgot to mention we moved from Germany, and I possess a valid German residence permit.
To clarify CSI = comprehensive sickness insurance.noajthan wrote:PS Very important![]()
If you wish your time in UK to count towards acquiring PR then you need to make sure you have CSI in place.
This catches a lot of people out![]()
Otherwise your PR clock will not be considered to be running & your time spent in studies (in UK) will not be counted.
If you were from EEA you could start by using an EHIC card but as an American you will have to shoot for a CSI policy.
Not really, they have legal obligation to ensure their students are legal and if in doubt......afairbairn wrote: I will continue to fight my case with them as this is a top rated uni and a graduate program. Their taking 18k from me, you would think they would be a bit more accepting.
The point is RC proves status.afairbairn wrote:noajthan,
Thank you for the response. I have been going back and forth with the Uni for about three weeks now about the whole situation. Unfortunately it was not until last Friday that they told me I need to get the EEA (FM) RC.
The last communication I had with the international student people at the uni was about if I get anything from the home office if I could register. The response was, "I’m afraid the University will be unable to register you until you have been given the final decision on your application." This was before I knew what a COA was, I have been doing a lot of reading since.
Clearly if I am to, not, have to reapply to the program next year this is not a possibility. Classes start next week and processing time for the RC is 6 months.
I will continue to fight my case with them as this is a top rated uni and a graduate program. Their taking 18k from me, you would think they would be a bit more accepting.
When I have the COA in hand I will probe them further.
Thanks again for your suggestions / help.
Jobseeker is legitimate way to exercise treaty rights.afairbairn wrote:I forgot to mention that my wife is a Jobseeker. She is in the last round of interviews for a position and it looks good. We collect no benefits from the UK and have no intent to. We do get unemployment from Germany brought over through new EU regs.
Interestingly I was denied the right to work here. Stamped in my passport at the border that I can stay for 6months and no right to work. Told by border control that I can stay as long as I want.
I could not get a National Insurance Number, and therefore could not work. Even thought they did not see my passport.
I though I could work for 3 months and once I get a COA if it allows me to work I can continue.
The whole thing is a bit odd to me. Way quicker and easier in Germany to get a RC.
I understand that they need to keep within the law. What EU laws are we talking here, I want to formulate a good argument for this? I have sent them copies of all my documents on a fees assessment information questionnaire and have not heard back.noajthan wrote:
The point is RC proves status.
You have German RC that proves you're a family member; albeit in Germany but all that has changed is location not relationship.
Try to persuade them this is EU laws at play rather than UK law.
fyi the uni will be penalised if they get it wrong which may explain their behaviour.
You should be on EEA fees too.
And afaik once you start you can't change so dont get trapped on international fees.
Again if uni want a definitive answer & won't accept COA try to use the RC you have to prove family member status.
This may be time for a quick intervention by good immigration lawyer as time is of the essence;
you obviously want to start & start on correct fees track (maybe apply for student finance on correct basis too).
Suggest find out what legal standing the German RC card has in its own right & in UK.afairbairn wrote:I understand that they need to keep within the law. What EU laws are we talking here, I want to formulate a good argument for this? I have sent them copies of all my documents on a fees assessment information questionnaire and have not heard back.noajthan wrote:
The point is RC proves status.
You have German RC that proves you're a family member; albeit in Germany but all that has changed is location not relationship.
Try to persuade them this is EU laws at play rather than UK law.
fyi the uni will be penalised if they get it wrong which may explain their behaviour.
You should be on EEA fees too.
And afaik once you start you can't change so dont get trapped on international fees.
Again if uni want a definitive answer & won't accept COA try to use the RC you have to prove family member status.
This may be time for a quick intervention by good immigration lawyer as time is of the essence;
you obviously want to start & start on correct fees track (maybe apply for student finance on correct basis too).
I may just contact a lawyer, it is probably worth it as opposed to having to wait another year and hope they accept my application again.
Thank you.
It sounds like you entered the UK under the visa waiver as an American citizen rather than under EU rules as a family member of an EEA citizen.afairbairn wrote:I understand that they need to keep within the law. What EU laws are we talking here, I want to formulate a good argument for this? I have sent them copies of all my documents on a fees assessment information questionnaire and have not heard back.noajthan wrote:
The point is RC proves status.
You have German RC that proves you're a family member; albeit in Germany but all that has changed is location not relationship.
Try to persuade them this is EU laws at play rather than UK law.
fyi the uni will be penalised if they get it wrong which may explain their behaviour.
You should be on EEA fees too.
And afaik once you start you can't change so dont get trapped on international fees.
Again if uni want a definitive answer & won't accept COA try to use the RC you have to prove family member status.
This may be time for a quick intervention by good immigration lawyer as time is of the essence;
you obviously want to start & start on correct fees track (maybe apply for student finance on correct basis too).
I may just contact a lawyer, it is probably worth it as opposed to having to wait another year and hope they accept my application again.
Thank you.
ALKB,ALKB wrote:It sounds like you entered the UK under the visa waiver as an American citizen rather than under EU rules as a family member of an EEA citizen.afairbairn wrote:I understand that they need to keep within the law. What EU laws are we talking here, I want to formulate a good argument for this? I have sent them copies of all my documents on a fees assessment information questionnaire and have not heard back.noajthan wrote:
The point is RC proves status.
You have German RC that proves you're a family member; albeit in Germany but all that has changed is location not relationship.
Try to persuade them this is EU laws at play rather than UK law.
fyi the uni will be penalised if they get it wrong which may explain their behaviour.
You should be on EEA fees too.
And afaik once you start you can't change so dont get trapped on international fees.
Again if uni want a definitive answer & won't accept COA try to use the RC you have to prove family member status.
This may be time for a quick intervention by good immigration lawyer as time is of the essence;
you obviously want to start & start on correct fees track (maybe apply for student finance on correct basis too).
I may just contact a lawyer, it is probably worth it as opposed to having to wait another year and hope they accept my application again.
Thank you.
The best thing would have been to get an EEA family permit before moving (no visa fee, processing time about 3 weeks including mailing documents back and forth) or to ask for a code 1A stamp at the border, showing your marriage certificate, etc. This gives you the right to work and study and should have been sufficient for enrolling in university while your application for a residence card is being processed.
You could possibly ask for your passport back, leave and re-enter the UK under EU rules but I doubt that this will be in time for your course to start.
By the way, have you and your wife unregistered when you left Germany? At the very latest, you need to do that once her unemployment benefits from Germany stop. Laws have changed relatively recently and as long as you are registered in Germany you have to have health insurance there. To cancel your health insurance, you need the Abmeldebescheinigung (de-registration certificate) or your health insurance will happily charge you at the highest rate until they receive that document.
As a non-UK national and new student, did you receive any guidance or advice upfront from the University?afairbairn wrote:...
ALKB,
I was considering the possibility of leaving and reentering. I have contacted a lawyer and am awaiting a response. We had issues at the border, initially border officers did not want to let me in. I travelled with my wife, and it was stated to them that she was exercising her treaty rights. We had to present them with marriage cert, proof of a place to live, and proof of money on bank accounts. They were making a stink about me not having anything from my university etc. I get the feeling that what they did was not in line with what they should have.
I wish I had my passport to see exactly what the stamp said in it. What I remember it was a stamp, stated I had to leave in 6months and that I had no right to work, but the officer said I do not have to leave and they can do nothing. You think they screwed me?
We are both still angemeldet in Germany and still have health insurance etc. So everything on that end is inline.
I think you didn't receive proper guidance from your university and you didn't read up enough on what is required of you as an international student, either.afairbairn wrote:...
ALKB,
I was considering the possibility of leaving and reentering. I have contacted a lawyer and am awaiting a response. We had issues at the border, initially border officers did not want to let me in. I travelled with my wife, and it was stated to them that she was exercising her treaty rights. We had to present them with marriage cert, proof of a place to live, and proof of money on bank accounts. They were making a stink about me not having anything from my university etc. I get the feeling that what they did was not in line with what they should have.
I wish I had my passport to see exactly what the stamp said in it. What I remember it was a stamp, stated I had to leave in 6months and that I had no right to work, but the officer said I do not have to leave and they can do nothing. You think they screwed me?
We are both still angemeldet in Germany and still have health insurance etc. So everything on that end is inline.
At time of application and acceptance of the offer I was just questioned about a Tier4 Student Visa. As my wife and I decided we were going to move prior to the begin of the programme I did not request needing one.noajthan wrote:
As a non-UK national and new student, did you receive any guidance or advice upfront from the University?
At the end of the day the onus is ofcourse on you as master of your own destiny;
however it is unfortunate if you were not clear well ahead of time what was needed and had to be done (bearing in mind processing times & other such practicalities by agencies such as Home Office, SFE & others).
noajthan wrote:Very informative & surely strengthens your case.
Not sure if your German RC was issued under German domestic law but it may back up this new input if Uni is shown it too.
Hopefully you can take up your place & on Home/EU fees basis.
Don't forget to sort that out too as, under SFE rules, you can't switch fees basis once you enrol/start the course.
afairbairn wrote:noajthan wrote:Very informative & surely strengthens your case.
Not sure if your German RC was issued under German domestic law but it may back up this new input if Uni is shown it too.
Hopefully you can take up your place & on Home/EU fees basis.
Don't forget to sort that out too as, under SFE rules, you can't switch fees basis once you enrol/start the course.
I have every intent of getting that all worked out ahead of registering. I have also emailed BAMF, the office of migration in Germany and requested information under what laws my RC there was issued as I could not find anything elsewhere. Still waiting to hear from them.
Thank you for the info! I do just have an aufenthaltstitel, and I was able to read further into everything, so it was just issued under domestic law.ALKB wrote: As your spouse is a German national, you most probably have a residence permit under domestic law (unless you and your spouse have previously lived and worked in a different EU country?).
If your biometric card says "Aufenthaltskarte" (residence card) it's under EU law. If it says "Aufenthaltstitel" (residence permit) it has been issued under German domestic law.
Both come in card form but only the EU one is actually officially called residence card.
-COA not CAS......afairbairn wrote: I have sent him copies of everything that I had, i.e. passport (not showing stamp), german rc and marriage certificate. I will be sending a letter our shortly to request my documents back from the Home Office, would anyone have an idea how long that can take? Otherwise I guess I am stuck until I get the COA and my documents back, a bit annoying as I Imagine this can take some time. On that same note, should I request a CAS be sent in the letter asking for my docs back or am I better off just waiting as it should come?
Thank you all.
There have been a few high-profile scandals involving even top-ranking UK universities & the registration of foreign students in recent years.afairbairn wrote:So the university finally got back to me this morning with the following email.
Details of your case have been forwarded to me ...
It appears that this essentially comes down to me proving my right to be here. Which had they sent me the above information prior to me sending away all my documents to the Home Office this would have been an easy task. Through the stamp on my passport, which if not the correct one as I suspect, would have given me the ability to goto a border control point and get a code 1A stamp.
I have sent him copies of everything that I had, i.e. passport (not showing stamp), german rc and marriage certificate. I will be sending a letter our shortly to request my documents back from the Home Office, would anyone have an idea how long that can take? Otherwise I guess I am stuck until I get the COA and my documents back, a bit annoying as I Imagine this can take some time. On that same note, should I request a CAS be sent in the letter asking for my docs back or am I better off just waiting as it should come?
Thank you all.