hi AKU
i have read your post very carefully and i almost have the same problem.
i think what happened in your situation is that when you got the refuel first time, if you would have appealed, then you would have been covered by 3c or 3d until the decision is made because 3c ad 3d would have extended your stay until all the appeal rights were exhausted, but if you have applied as a fresh application they do not consider it as an appeal or 3c 3d because you have not excersided your rights of it by using 3c or 3d. and because of that it states in the guidance of the long residence file, that if you do not appeal, and at the time of your new application, if you do not have a valid visa,(which you didn't have because it was expired) then the overstay will be counted from the date from which the visa is expired until the date a new one is issued.
but in your situation, you did have a right of appeal, which could also mean that maybe they would have considered your application as in time application.
when i received my SAR report, in one of the case worker notes, it stated that my application was out of time, may be you should try to look for the relevant years case worker notes and somewhere in there it should mention wether your application was considered in time or out of time.
the other thing is that before 2012 april rules, if you would have received a refusal, you automatically have 28 day to apply no matter if you have a current leave or not, and that period would not be counted as an overstayer, but because you haven't applied before 2012 for you LR application, those rules are not valid any more.
please refer this in guidance for 10 year long residency guidance and if you type ctrl + F, a search bar on top right corner of the page will come up, if you right there "out of time application" and press the right arrow it will then take you to the correct page on which all of this is explained properly.
i hope this helps.
my prayers are with you.
PLEASE DONOT FORGET TO UPDATE THE OUTCOME OF YOU APPLICATION FOR OUR HELPS ASWELL.
TAKE CARE
AKU wrote:Hello AKU ,
i have found the example of the similar case as yours in their website regarding overstaying and after going through your case and the case example in their case i don't think so you overstayed i don't know why on your SAR report its saying overstay start from july 2006

Check the dates again ? hope your post is free from any type error :-
for your satisfaction and other members on this forum have a look on this example mentioned on page number 9 of ilr overstayer documents :-
In-time application refused, appeal right not exercised
The migrant had leave until 1 March 2012 and submitted an application for further leave on
26 February 2012. The application was refused on 31 July 2012, but the migrant did not
exercise their right of appeal.
In this case the migrant’s leave was extended during the period:
their application was awaiting determination, and
they could have brought an appeal against the refusal decision.
Therefore the migrant began overstaying on 17 August 2012, based on:
case refused on 31 July 2012
adding two days for deemed postal service gives 2 August 2012
adding 10 working days while an in-time appeal could be brought gives 16 August
2012
first day of overstaying is 17 August 2012.
https://www.gov.uk/government/uploads/s ... 5.0EXT.pdf
Or i think you have to find the rules before 9th july 2012 regarding overstaying because the link which i have provided is clearly saying on or after 9th july 2012 ....or probably i might wrong , shahjee can shed a light on it ...
I think you should be okay but let see what will be the out come of your application ....Did you consult any solicitor before you submitted your case i understand that by that time you had no SAR report but still did you took any advice on it ...
Keep updating us ,
Regards ,
S.Akaram
Hi S.Akaram
I have just read that & I'm also not sure why the SAR states he had overstayed from 1
st June 2006
I pray that whoever is considering the ILR will realize this. Will keep the faith and wait for the outcome.
Thank you all for your input on this forum, it is really helpful. God bless you all[/quote]