I am not a great fan of the English Language and i make no boast of being knowledgeable of it. However i believe that by definition a person creating fear or fright is a Scaremonger.
Based on the statement you posited, I am not sure that i wrongly accused you.
I will give you a small example.
Since February 2017, i have received 12 application decision on ID requirements. 3 of those applicants did not produce ID and were granted, as Home Office accepted the explanition given. Similar explanitions were given for a further 6 of those case, which were refused and an appeal pending, and the other 3 were overturned following a threat of JR.
It will be silly on the basis of those 6 successful cases for me to come on the forum and say that don't worry people, don't send ID, and you will get residence. That will be wholly reckless.
It is safer for me to say, the requirement to provide an ID is unlawful and there is a high prospect of success. That will be the most accurate thing to say, will it not, even though i have seen some of my cases without ID being successful.