There is no fixed time for Zambrano applications. Some people are waiting several months for decision. You could send an email to the department to an update.

Good Outcome, glad you got laughter in the end after the Long Journey.

A person will have a right under the 2015 regulations in Ireland even without a Residence permit, as permit does not confer any rights only if the qualifying criteria are met can a right be established. Uk residence card or settled permit or whatever they call it these days does not permit you any r...

That document is nonsense, we will have to fight it at the courts. This hopeless and hapless government, always trying to put immigrants in the back foot to undermine their rights. On the one hand they keep saying in court that migrant cannot expect EU law and domestic law to be treated as same, now...

jmedina wrote: ↑

Tue May 14, 2019 6:58 pm

I am not sure if Surinder Singh applies for unmarried partners. It clearly states on eligibility "spouse (husband or wife) or civil partner".
Did you get any advice before applying?

Yes it does apply. The regulations has been amended to include extended family members.

How long has your marriage lasted for?

There is no pm facility for any new user.

finalversion_2k wrote: ↑

Mon May 13, 2019 10:13 am

@OBIE : correct me If I'm not wrong, you are saying if Irish mrrg dissolve before 3 years, NON-EU don't have any option to secure his status?? as you said EU5 is for EUs not for Irish??

Correct, that is what I am saying.

while on separation you can't do anything as per law & Rules.. you have to divorce and then need to apply for Retention of rights EU5 form. EU5 form: http://www.inis.gov.ie/en/INIS/form-EUTR5.pdf/Files/form-EUTR5.pdf Explanatory Leaflet: http://www.inis.gov.ie/en/INIS/Form%20EU5%20Explanatory%20Lea...

The whole explanation is too ambiguous. I am thinking of applying extension of leave to remain until I find out the real route to go. I don't also know my chances. It's terrible for me now and I am not composed at the moment. Wish you all the best. If you are unable to succeed under EU law which pr...

If a person's Stamp 4 EU fam is revoked because the EU citizen has ceased from residing in the state, then the revocation commences from the time the minister notified the person of this. A child born to the person before the revocation, provided the person has resided in Ireland for the relevant pe...

New evidence is a no no. There is a push back on new grounds for appeal in that new matters not under previous consideration will not be readily entertained. The throw everything and the k i t c h e n sink mentality at PAP and JR is not cutting any ice and diminishes the overall case when it comes ...

Really unclear what evidence you are currently in possession of, and the full circumstances of you and your ex wife at the time of initiation of divorce proceedings, so it is hard to express a view.

Frontier Mole wrote: ↑

Sun May 12, 2019 12:16 am

. Rarely do new grounds get allowed into consideration for permission to appeal.

Please do not get your expectations raised too high.

Do you mean new evidence?

That is not possible, reconsideration would work only if at the time of application you met the requirements.

I do not think you have complete evidence to qualify for a retained right.

You could qualify for PR, but as you said, there is no complete evidence of working for a complete period of 5 years to enable you to qualify under this route.

If you are in the UK and Tier 2, working and earning, then it will not work, as you will not be considered as dependant. You can only qualify if you are under 21. The solicitor did not give you full story.

In your case, they lawfully revoked, and you sought a review of that decision. The court in Ireland has ruled that during the review process a person's stamp 4 must be extended pending the outcome, and in the end the minister granted stamp 4, so my thinking is that reconnable residence was not broke...

Hi Thanks for your response. I have applied for EU1 under treaty rights and have got a refusal and not appealing under EU4 application and while that application is under review - can I come back to UK , bring my dependants(Parents) and apply for UK residency? Given the stringent nature of the UK S...

They have a duty to OP to provide him with these details. If they delay or refused to do so maliciously, then it is open to him to make a complain to the SRA, notify the FTT about this in his application for permission to appeal to the UT.

If an extended family member cease from being a dependent or member of the household of a union citizen, then they lose their right as family member under regulation 7(3) and hence cannot accrue rights for the purpose of regulation 15(1) (b).