Hi All,

My husband is coming to the end of his 5 years residence soon her in Ireland based on EU TREATY rights.

I am a UK citizen. Do we still apply on the EU3 form for permanent residence?

If not, what do we do?

Thanks!

Hello All, My mother-in-law's review for EU1 dependant was refused, based on not supplying enough proof of giving her money and for the fact I am on PUP since May, which i think is unfair as it's not my fault. She has been here for 4 years now. We pay everything for her and provide all documents sh...

Hello All, My mother-in-law's review for EU1 dependant was refused, based on not supplying enough proof of giving her money and for the fact I am on PUP since May, which i think is unfair as it's not my fault. She has been here for 4 years now. We pay everything for her and provide all documents sh...

Hello All, My mother-in-law's review for EU1 dependant was refused, based on not supplying enough proof of giving her money and for the fact I am on PUP since May, which i think is unfair as it's not my fault. She has been here for 4 years now. We pay everything for her and provide all documents sho...

Yes, it is crazy. No, they didn’t change their mind. The Minister refused her EUFAM residence card because apparatus we didn’t provide evidence of dependency in the State. I wrote back in my review that I have read all the law and we provided every proof of dependancy in Ghana otherwise they would n...

There were no stories or anything to try to convince anyone. Everything was genuine application. She came under RU Treaty rights to stay. So now we just need to know what can we do since it’s been three years.

Yes everything was made clear she was coming to stay under Eu treaty rights. Even on the c visa it stated member of an eu citezen and you had 90 days to apply for your EUFAM card. For people that are just coming to visit they also are issued with a c visa. But under eu treaty rights it’s different.

Hi, It was under Eu treaty rights. My husband also came with me to Ireland on a c visa for EU treaty roghts. The quote that you have posted from Inis website has nothing to do with Eu Treaty rights, otherwise no qualifying member can come as a dependant because they are not dependent if they have ti...

And I mean she came under Eu Treaty Rights because all the evidence was there that she was dependant on me for years when she lived in Ghana. Now she is here for more than 3 years, completely dependant on us.

Hi, Sorry if I wasn’t clear. She didn’t come as a visitor. She came on a C Visa under Eu Treaty Rights. She applied from Ghana and ticked the box that it was as a dependent of an Eu Citizen. She passed all yhe documentation showing I provided for her while I was in Ghana. She came here under Eu Trea...

Hello What's her immigration history? How did the story start and what kind of visa did she use to enter Ireland? Hi, I think the administrators added my post to my previous posts so the long story is there. But long story short, She came with a c vida under eu treaty rights, we submitted EU1 appli...

Hi All, My mother in Law application Eu1 was refused in 3018. We submitted review. Just to make things faster - all documents perfect nothing wrong for review. Now, they have extended again until next year, her application is still in the queue. I want to know, is there anything we can do since she ...

It is still ongoing. It has been 2 years since I applied for a review.

npayne - did you get any outcome of your review in the end or still waiting? Hi Capricorn, She just got another extension for a further 6 months. This will be 3 years living in Ireland now. She has Type 2 Diabetes and painful feet, we pay for all her doctor appointments, which are not many, but 50 ...

Hi, I am British, but I can get Irish Citizenship based on my family. I want to apply and get an Irish passport. Will this effect my husband and mother-in-law EUFAM rights because I am both Irish and British? Should I wait to become Irish after they get their permanent residence cards? Husband will ...

Hi! Yes I did, they said because he is my husband and he is under EU Treaty Rights, we can apply. He doesn't need to have permanent residency first. We need to wait a year or two to apply though, just to save the rest of the deposit and make sure we have a good yearly income to increase the chances ...

Hi, Did you show or have proof that the rent and utility bills are being paid from your money? Like if her name is on the tenancy and utility bill in her name, did you show that you paid it or you just assumed they knew you paid it? If you just assumed and didn't show that you paid it or gave her mo...

Hi all, I might be mistaken, i think I read it i. The regulations a couple years ago but can a spouse of eu who has a 5 year residence card apply for the permanent one earlier than the 5 years? We want yo buy a house, but not sure if Rebuilding Ireland scheme will accept my husbands stamp 4, even th...

Hi all, has anyone been able to buy a house with the rebuilding Ireland government mortgage if your EU spouse has indefinite leave to remain but your non eu has a stamp 4? My husband will qualify for permanent residence in 2 years, but we were hoping to buy a house soon as our rent is crazy, but whe...

Thank you for replying. I will look into seeing if getting one will be troublesome or not, as it’s not a big deal if she comes in the trip or stats here at home, it would just be nice for her to come and see some of the UK.

Hello, I have tesco vouchers which I want to use on the ferry to visit my family in UK. I want my mother in law to join us on the trip. She currently has a stamp 4 as her review application is in the queue. She was refused but we appealed review. Will she be allowed to come and come back into Irelan...

hi npayne, My mother was refused in june 2017. We appealed for review, they refused for same reason. She is dependant on me from last 3 years in ireland and have serious medical conditions. She was given 3 extension (9 month, 4 months and 10 months) and then no further extension. we receive a lette...

Hi, My My mum in law was also refused in I think March 2018. We appealed without a solicitor. They refused for the same reason in your letter but the difference was they wrote not dependant on us in the state. We have provided every document possible proving her dependency back in her home country f...

Waiting for opinions or advice

Thanks