The reason was the same as yours. Applicant’s track record and contributions to the field to date, relative to career stage, were not strong enough. Reason was quite ambiguous, so I had to appeal. There was a separate email with a pdf, but that didn’t give any further details. It was the exact same...

Hi Please can you share the needed documents required for the endorsement? That is, what are the evidences you need to show to the endorsement body? Thanks. All required documents are clearly stated in the guidelines. For promise category, You will need letter from UK person, personal statement, CV...

“applicant’s track record and contributions to the field to date, relative to career stage ”. How old are you if you don't mind? Your credentials are not evaluated as an absolute value. They are compared to your age and put in perspective. The older you are, the higher is the expectation. This mean...

It took 26 working days for me.
What reason they have given to you.
Have you only got email of refusal or seperate pdf attached to it mentioning reason for refusal.

Yes I did and refusal again.
What about your application?

Is it with Royal Society too?

Please share your timeline, if possible.
Thanks

Less rejection and very few apply to Royal Society I guess, could be the reason.
I need detailed feedback to appeal the decision.

What is the status of your application?

ramgoel123 wrote: ↑

Tue Jan 15, 2019 1:58 pm

I think you are lucky that technation has provided you feedback in such detail. Fresh application is your choice if you can cover all.open questions in feedback.

Do they not always provide detailed feedback? I have applied with Royal society but haven't got detailed feedback.

Yes My qualifications are obtained from UK and working in research and development in industry. I am not member of any professional body or society. They normally provide two PDFs with refusal email one with standard endorsement form and other with detailed feedback of refusal stating that why do th...

Application for Exceptional Promise submitted on 10 November. URN recieved 15 November and refusal email on 14 December. Yes I have PhD, research papers, leeter from UK person and fulfill all major criteria. Refusal state that applicant’s track record and contributions to the field to date, relative...

I have got refusal but no feedback.

Hi D_social,

Have you got two PDF with the rejection email? One is decision and other is detailed feedback. Your answer would be helpful. Thank you.

Wish you all the best for the review.

Hi all,
Does anyone here applied under Royal Society and got refusal? Have you got feedback for refusal from them?
Thank you