No need for a visa for her. Just jump on a plane and off you go. The landing in UK will be via domestic terminal so no issue at that end. The airline staff in Ireland will ask for her visa which will be the Stamp4EuFam. They may ask you to go to their desk and have the boarding card stamped as visa ...

Yes and No, Yes, For people who were originally given a Temp Stamp 4, both direct and permitted family members. Its not normally automatic thou. You gotta write to them asking for decision/extension and then they issue a letter with 2-3 months extension. You take that to Garda and they renew the car...

My brother's appeal pending since Oct 15. No reply still. Permitted (Extended) family member case.

Hi guys, Just to share some info related to PEO applications when there is late filing or amendments of tax returns involved for earlier years. Apparently, the PEOs do not have access to live HMRC data but they have HMRC data saved up on their systems at a certain point in history and hence these re...

Right, ok,

Good luck man. I hope they offer you guys an out of court settlement.

Do u know if JR outcomes in ireland are similar to UK where the losing side pays the costs to the other side?

Hi Malik,

How did the JR hearing go?

Dear owsiddiqui, Let me try to answer your queries, although I request the seniors to correct me where I go wrong: 1) Yes, it refer to a visa/family permit, however it is eligible on Direct family members and not permitted members. The border staff will not give FP/Visa to a permitted member on arri...

Hi the documents you have provide are more then enough but the problem in Ireland that there is not Tribunal system as in UK, if there was Immigration Tribunal and full right of appeal was given then i am 100 percent sure will were able to appeal allowed. now my brother case is same like you but th...

@Premier2013, Thanks for your message above. Didn't realize you sent this message earlier in the year until today. I must give you credit for your predictions. They did approve my mum's but refused my brother's with some lame excuse. Given the right to review which we sent in last week. So another w...

Thanks Obie, No, they haven't mentioned anything about legal/illegal entry as yet. The reason I asked is that they refused another member's review in a very similar case quoting that he was illegal in UK before entering IE via NI and that he entered IE illegally so we don't accept your dependency. M...

@Obie, A quick question in relation to my brother's EU1 application and our initial travel into Ireland. Can our review application be legally refused merely on the point that he didn't take a family permit before entering Ireland, i.e, hence he entered illegally so they refuse his application? My u...

Hi, I am in process of sending the review out this week. For people who are waiting for their 5-year responses, it does come before the 7 months stamp 4 expires as "Adedayoh mentioned. My response timeline was as follows: 10/03/2015, EU1 application reached INIS. Application response deadline 09/09/...

Any help guys?

You are right @ Obie.
How best to report the incident? Do I report it to Solvit or INIS or some other department? I dont even know her name man.

Could you also please shed some light on the refusal reasons quoted. Are they not supposed to explain why they are refusing, etc?

Obie wrote:Such behaviour merits a complaint I will say.

How best you suggest to do that? Could it cause issues to us later on as she may take it rather personal. What do you think?

Back in UK now getting all the docs collated for my brother's review. Guys please advise how best to respond/prepare for the review. As I mentioned, no specifics given, don't mention what's missing. Just says: "You have failed to submit satisfactory evidence of dependence on the EU citizen including...

Hi Guys, As informed before, I went to GNIB Dublin to get my mum's card on Friday. The queue is quite long however, they are processing it quite quickly. I got there for 4:30am and was about #60 in the queue. The activities start around 7:15 when the guys came to straighten up the queues and they fi...

Hi Tsdhot, V got ours through yesterday too. They dropped card so i went to pick it up in the afternoon. Mixed response in our case. They have approved my mums application but refused my brother's unfortunately. No specific reason given, just say you failed to provide satisfactory evidence, dont men...

Hi Tsdhot,

Anything in the post today?

Nothing at my end yet.

No man, nothing in the post today too.

@Obie, I was speaking to a friend yesterday who has been living in Ireland for a good number of years under EU rights. He advised me yesterday that his response was issued couple of days past his 6-month Temp 4 stamp which caused him to loose his initial temp period when applying for IE naturalisati...

Anything in the post today Tsdhot?

Hi, I can only partly answer your questions. From what I can understand from your post, your spouse is currently exercising her treaty rights(working) in UK and you have been given a 5-year EU residence card by the UK. Following a recent court ruling, you do not need a visa (family permit) to travel...

Hi,
Read and search information regarding Surinder Singh route. There is plenty of information about it on this forum. There is also a BBC documentary which you can search via google easily.

@Tsdhot. Anything in today's post my friend?