That is the point i was seeking to make. You cannot put a target on human being. It is an unethical practice and likely to result in innocent victims. You can put performance target on application processing, on how quickly to answer calls. However you cannot put target on how many people should be...

That is the point i was seeking to make. You cannot put a target on human being. It is an unethical practice and likely to result in innocent victims. You can put performance target on application processing, on how quickly to answer calls. However you cannot put target on how many people should be...

Hi Obie, you are coming across as a crazy dearly beloved 😉, which I know you're not. Just take a step back. Windrush, absolutely, they got it wrong. BUT Illegals, YOU are wrong- they are not here legally. If most of the illegals are blackbrown, not white, thats hardly the governments fault. Whatever...

You must complete a full 5 years from the date your residence card was issued and your partner must be a qualified person exercising treaty rights for the whole 5 year period. I can't answer your other question. I thought it was from the date you entered the UK? Or is that just SS route? For a long...

https://amp.theguardian.com/business/20 ... lders-loom

How can people check whether they are on the list held by HO?

Well it appears that the updated Surinder Singh guidelines, with their transitional arrangements, completely fix my problem! Because my RC was issued prior to November 2016 my husband will be considered qualified up until that period - after which he has had a job, so I didn't need to have CSI at a...

Thank you very much. This is very interesting. It basically waives the CSI requirement and the requirement for the BC to be a qualified person before 25.11.16 if I am reading this correctly? Very good they are putting forward transitional arrangements. Would love to see a detailed legal analysis of...

That case was decided by the EFTA Court who's judgments are not binding on the UK as we are a full member of the EU. It is like any other court which has to take account of CJEU case law. I can't see how this judgment would help. Well, yes EFTA but isn't O&B and the EFTA judgement what UK are relyi...

Back on topic. How does one rely on Article 45 when O and B Netherlands more or less rewrites Singh and earlier case law? In paragraph 54 of O and B the CJEU courts underlying objective was not to deter the EU nationals movement. The UK regulations as they are currently have the effect of detering ...

hilarious!
Don't know what the whiff of beloved was, but anyhooo....have a great day!
Lol, r-a-c-i-s-t= beloved...good one mods

So do you think I will be okay and the last three years will count or should I be worried ? And try and think of alternative arrangements for my Mum Dad husband and kids and find a work and not care for them anymore? I’m so confused I do t know what to do I’m so worried. Thank you for everyone’s re...

Greatscott I would definitely be interested in helping please let me know I can’t help a lot but whatever I can I will help. Thanks, it would need to be a coordinated group effort headed by someone who understands crowdfunding. Set up a trust of some sort, then use the funds to help vulnerable appl...

So do you think I will be okay and the last three years will count or should I be worried ? And try and think of alternative arrangements for my Mum Dad husband and kids and find a work and not care for them anymore? I’m so confused I do t know what to do I’m so worried. Thank you for everyone’s re...

Under SS, there is no need for you to have worked according to Eind case law. No-one on this forum, on any government web site, or anywhere in the public domain can prove that Eind law has been overturned. Therefore it still applies. What the UK government is trying to do since 25 November 2016, is...

Under SS, there is no need for you to have worked according to Eind case law. No-one on this forum, on any government web site, or anywhere in the public domain can prove that Eind law has been overturned. Therefore it still applies. What the UK government is trying to do since 25 November 2016, is ...

I believe Surinder Singh would be covered under Article 21(1) TFEU. When a British Citizen exercises his or her Treaty rights and returns to the Member State of his origin, Article 21(1) TFEU confers on their non-EEA national family members a derived right of residence. EU citizens resident in acco...

Assuming you are working?? There was a bit of a rule change late last year re SS route.

This is not correct. Please refer us to EEA regulations overturning Eind case law.

Surely the employer can just ring Home Office and get employee status confirmed? Not having a RC is not, as far as we've been told on these forums, a requirement to be able to work.

The lack of any reply leads me to think more about the problem. We were taught in evaluating a legal agreement, that the worst thing one could do was to change a few lines here, rephrase a sentence there, and so on....because it would create a legal mess as everything in a well put together agreemen...

We were on a slightly different trajectory Piet, and we played it safe by not going out the country until RC received......BUT.....in your case the COA (you receive a couple of weeks after RC application sent) would surely do the job. Thats my contribution, happy to be corrected....and good luck. He...

Hello Piet, I will give you my advice. This forum was very good, but seems a little loose these days. The really clever guys seem to have withdrawn a bit. 1. Dont need FP, can apply straight for RC 2. Send a self addressed registered envelope with (your post office will do this for you) and also in ...

Or maybe someone could point me to the correct government web site for answers? Or should we just wait? If we wait maybe thats an illegal act? Could we get an employer into trouble? Should we lie to the employer? Best not I guess....what then should we tell this employer? Should we offer to indemnif...

Maybe I should send both completed forms with £65 and ask them to choose which application they prefer?

Anyone have any advice? I can't find anything on .gov.uk about this situation.

Anyone?

Direct family member arrived as non eu dependant of BC via Surinder Singh route under 21. Person is now over 21, earns a salary BUT still lives with his parents.....gov.uk says for extended family members "you are still dependant on them or are still a member of their household ". So in this case t...