This is unfortunately what I was suspecting to be the case, but I think this is very sad at the same time that people are treated this way. 10 years? It’s like they ever made it easy for people to come here in the first place. But thank you anyways for all info.

She was a student here in the UK and drop out back in 2011, due to some problems with the College not accepting her to pay her fees in monthly instalments. Then we attempted to get married here and she got caught in 2012 prior to the ceremony. We went through a lengthy process of getting her residen...

Do you know any specific cases where similar situation led to refusal? or you just infer your view based on logical deduction?

no offence, just trying to make sure I should abandon efforts at this time.

thanks for answering anyways.

Ok thanks, I was pretty sure I read something on the forum in the past that once you enter UK under EU rules the past record under British rules would be removed from the database? Maybe I got it wrong...

Will a person who previously been removed from the UK and returned under EU rules as spouse of EU citizen, then obtained permanent residence card would be eligible to apply for British Citizenship? does the removal would affect the application? perhaps under good character consideration or otherwise...

And also some stuff about evidence of sponsorship that was provided by me th father like my letter of support and income of her and mine.

Thanks,

I've just finished my appeal, I did not write about being family member but that she has the right to accompany and that would need comprehensive insurance when here in the UK and that we applied for right of entry and not residence.

Thank you Obie for your input. I do intend to appeal because I feel that based on all the previous Case laws it was made clear how generous are these right for EU citizens and their family members. I will try to argue that in my appeal by stating the right of initial residence and right of entry. Ba...

Never heard about this case. He is 8 years old. Interesting to find out about this case.

Yes I could, then after my son is here,would she need to prove that she has enough resources to come here or only the child? Thank you

Thank you Simon, but that doesn't really answer my problem regarding mothers right to obtain family permit to accompany him there as a minor for the first 3 months of stay.

Dear Members, If any of you could enlighten me a bit about my situation, and where i go wrong with it or perhaps I am even right to some extent? The mother of my child non-EEA applied for a Family Permit to the UK. She was refused the visa under Chen regulations that she does not meet the criteria s...

Casa i would much appreciate if you didnt make your own conclusiions on others people lives that you have no idea about. Your nasty comment is " unwanted package" it just shows how ignorant you are. Yes if i became british citizen i believe their legal right to stay here and attempt to poison my lif...

Ok thanks, guys that clarified the matter> This was my original plan to wait but because I believe I made a mistake by letting my wife's dependent parents come here under EEA as well. They are trying to say big thank you to me by slandering me in the eyes of other people and contacting solicitors to...

Hello to All, My question is as follows: My wife and I have been already to the UK since 2013, before that she was removed from the UK as an overstaying student(I knew her at that time and we were in a relationship), however, we fought hard after our marriage and successfully won the appeal for her ...

I am willing to send you scanned copy of the document if you are interested.

It is family permit case and they are still in the Philippines, but the appeal was allowed and even Judge decided they need to pay us fees back, however he seems to be treating them as extended family members instead of direct family members. My case was quite simple I said that they should be issue...

I think it has to do with regulation 7 right? but how about the question of dependency where do I find more about it in regulations?

Obie could you please help, which regulations I should be looking at? I am trying to find regulations which apply to their case but I am a bit confused. thank you , I will appreciate if you could. I also understand that I should be asking for administrative review of this case right? I would really ...

Good day I've just received my parents appeal decision from the Tribunal which allowed their appeals. I am suppose to be very happy right? but it seems there is some problem with it, I was hoping someone could help me to clarify this problem. So in January this year my parents in-law applied for a f...

has she got European Residence Card from Germany? I think it should be much easier nowadays as the Judgment on travel with residence card was already out last year. We traveled by couch from Paris to London at night. It seemed that most British Officers sleep at that time because there were only Fre...

So here is another question I wonder what experienced users of this forum think. Around 4 months ago My parents in-law had applied for entry visa to UK which was refused. So I decided to make an appeal. The reason stated was that father of my wife was in receipt of aroung 42 british pounds from othe...

Thank you Vinny that's what I thought however having had all that experience that I had with UKBA I am bit worried that they may view that situation in a different way. I know there are certain documents that ECOs suppose to use them as guidance, do you know maybe if there is any information that de...

I hope someone could enlighten me because I am confused a little. If I got my PR but after acquiring it I became a student does my non-eu wife would still need to prove her right to permanent residence by means of Comprehensive Insurance upon completion of her 5 years with me here? Much appreciated ...

Well, In the case of me and my wife, we both applied for residency card but only one fee was deducted and I believe it was for me EEA national. I don't know why it happened that way but I suppose they didn't want to charge her because they haven't decided her application and then she got her refusal...