Hi Gistmaster , Note that I will be going on another holiday shortly, but will spare few minutes to give a few information. 1- If you are sure that you are actually exercising treaty rights in Eire, then you need to be more forceful with the treaty rights section and tell them to give your mum the s...
hi, Interesting discussion. Note that the only relevant case law for EU family member -parents is: http://eur-lex.europa.eu/LexUriServ/LexUriServ.do?uri=CELEX:62005J0001:EN:HTML 2 useful paragraphs : '37 In order to determine whether the relatives in the ascending line of the spouse of a Community n...
Hi Nemo, You don't need to explain dependence in India. Just say that they were dependent on you from Uk( with proof) which lead to ur going to Ireland. also state that this was ur basis of being given entry permission to Ireland, and not for visit. Thus it will be clear that they are were and are d...
Hi,, Making an application for RC in Ireland is not the same as your parents having a right of entry as dependents when they first entered Ireland. I'm only trying to be honest to give you the option that will give you absolute power over your rights. Unless Uk is absolutely sure that the permission...
Hi Nemo, There are two ways you can now absolutely obtain a right for your parents under surringer singh based on your circumstances: 1- Present with your parents to the UK (Through any means that will not lead to more problems), and apply for Residence card for them. Note that you will have to show...
Hi, FURTHER TO MY PREVIOUS POST, You also need to show dependency in Uk prior to going to Ireland to show that your parents were not just going for a visit. It will be your responsibility to prove this otherwise the officer will assume it was for a visit. Ie you prove that your parents went to Irela...
Hi, I think the officer was trying to interprete surinder Singh literarily. They are saying that you are not currently in the UK with your parents to benefit from the case law. The first 'EU State' mentioned is the UK, and the second 'Eu state' is IRELAND, from reading the reasons for refusal. Also,...
Hi, Further to my previous post. Adding a picture of you and your mum in your residence( outside, capturing the house number) will be a pictorial way to explain membership of your household in addition to registering her with a GP and ask GP to confirm the registration to your address. This should b...
Hi Treefriend, Its unfortunate that your mother was refused the residence card. From the website that Jinkazama provided, and the UK case law it is wrong for the officer to refuse your mum. Dependency is used in the current tense, and not past tense in EU law. It would have been best if you included...
hi ! Just a correction to my last post as I got some facts mixed up. unfortunately, I am more aware of the process in the uk and some other eu countries than in Ireland. But the facts remain the same. This is what the directive says: Right of entry 1. Without prejudice to the provisions on travel do...
Hi, Its nice to be able to be of help. Regarding Ireland, I see that there is no formal application form for EU Permit on its website. an Eu citizen should never allow their dependent family family member to apply for a VISA to Ireland. If you do this, they will claim that you chose to go by the imm...
Looks nice. You may want to add that: can the response be followed by the name of the person attending to the email, so that You can be very specific with the source of the information.
You should also give him link to the amended version of the SI 656 I gave you. Unlike in some visa applications, it is not the officers responsibilty to tell you your rights. It is up to you to find them, present them, and if refused you take legal action. I'll say send the final letter asking for t...
Hi, My guess was right. You started by asking about a visa application for your parent (as an eu citizen). You should be very specific about terminology in dealing with Eu cases. Your parent want a EU FAMILY PERMIT to Ireland, not a visa. Also, the omission of lawful residence was not an accident bu...
Hi J, Both options are valid. If I were you, I would write again to the person stating that you want to know if that is her own impression of the Eu legislation, or is it that of the Minister for Justice. You can also state that you need this information in order to make a complaint to solvit. Reite...
Hi, Yes. Eu permit is a Multi entry permit for 6 months if you qualify. Within that time you should apply for Eu card for family member if u are exercising treaty rights and show that you will qualify to exercise it beyond 3 months( read details in Inis website Please share your experience. Good luc...
Hi, Sorry I am not regular at this forum, just do so when I am jobless. however I am very abreast of Eu laws and its annoying when countries implement it badly. Read the amended part of the paragraph you quoted: http://www.inis.gov.ie/en/INIS/SI%20310%20of%202008.pdf/Files/SI%20310%20of%202008.pdf A...
Hi Jinkazama, Just another correction. Ireland will have to make a decision on your mums application within 15 days/ maximum of 1 month for EU family permit, and not 6 months (which is for EU treaty right). Best thing for you is to talk to a solicitor. You would have a right to know the reasons for ...
Hi Kinkazama, Its a big lie. The actual instrument is SI 656 of 2006 and not '256'. Also Article 5 (b) states: (b) documentary evidence from the relevant authority in the country of origin or country from which he or she is arriving certifying that he or she is a dependant, or a member of the househ...
Hi, Regarding travelling Ireland with a dependent mother, I want to say that it is entirely wrong for the Irish embassy in London to advise you that your mother( of the person who asked the question) is required to have lawful residence in UK before application will be accepted by the Irish embassy ...
