Good and logical judgment. Unfortunately not a binding authority, so home office may want to continue pushing its luck. Hi Vinny, Could you translate what do you mean in more simple terms for the general audience? Looking at the decision? was this on favour of Mr Sivakumar and her German Spouse? I ...

Hi Reynal. I was student I married my wife in 2012 may .but I apply for EEA January 2013 .so I apply for pr in jun 2017 .i accounting 5 year from date of marriage.and than I got refused because my wife she became British citizens in March 2013 . Hi Ron121, Many thanks for the info. I appreciate tha...

Hi chao . Yes I did mentioned Lounes Many thanks for sharing the progress of your appeal Ron121. May i know one more piece of information. Do you remember roughly when did you submit your application for the a Residence Card back in 2012 or when did you get your Family Member visa/entry clearance?....

Hello, From Success82 initial post telling us their story, my understanding is that they are also not covered by TA: "I got married to EU citizen in November 2012, applied for residence card in December 2012, got my 5yr residence vignette in my passport in Feb 2013..." As reynaldogr notes in post a...

Hi mate, Just to clarify 3 things about your previous post, to avoid anyone in this forum getting confuse: 1) Success82 did mention that her spouse was BC in the “other nationalities” section of the sponsor. I had personally asked her about this and she answered, with a YES. So she didn’t hide anyt...

chaoscontrol, i believe almost all your questions have been answered by success82, please read all the post above. I have also asked you a couple of questions RE your MP position on the HO reply to your letter. Many thanks Hi , sorry had no time to properly read everything as been at work till late...

I am a silent reader of this forum like Salu(post above) and i started following the board back in December 2012 when i applied for my 5year EEA residence card and shared my timeline and this is my story (I hope this encourage everyone in dual eea/uk cases).......I got married to EU citizen in Nove...

[quote=reynaldogr post_id=1602017 time=1519404596 user_id=189084] [quote=Navaro2 post_id=1602005 time=1519403509 user_id=91849] Important : Had a phone call from my MP today morning, she received an answer from UKVI (Home Office) to the letter which I send to her around month ago . THE ANSWER said :...

In my thoughts EEA citizens are covered by Brexit Withdrawal Agreement so only EEA citizenship holders will be eligible for EEA rules even after Brexit but what about dual EEA/UK citizens who are covered by Lounes judgement ? thanks to all . mgb wrote: ↑Wed Feb 21, 2018 12:48 am A application start...

UK is still under EU regulations and will be till or even after Brexit. However ECJ is going to be the arbiter for next 8 years after Brexit so every court will challenge HO. That letter was absolutely wrong without any sense Hi Navaro2, Check on this post made by Chaoscontrol in another similar fo...

I am a silent reader of this forum like Salu(post above) and i started following the board back in December 2012 when i applied for my 5year EEA residence card and shared my timeline and this is my story (I hope this encourage everyone in dual eea/uk cases).......I got married to EU citizen in Nove...

I am a silent reader of this forum like Salu(post above) and i started following the board back in December 2012 when i applied for my 5year EEA residence card and shared my timeline and this is my story (I hope this encourage everyone in dual eea/uk cases).......I got married to EU citizen in Nove...

My Indonesian wife had been waiting for a spouse of EU citizen visa for over a year. We got the decision a couple of days ago. It's been refused because I hold Irish nationality (through naturalisation since 2016). I'm a Pole and I've spent most of my life in Poland, but they claim that Ireland is ...

Thanks for advice mgb , that will be definately the fact for the court listing after appeal . Important : Had a phone call from my MP today morning, she received an answer from UKVI (Home Office) to the letter which I send to her around month ago . THE ANSWER said : ALL EUROPEAN COURT RULINGS/DECIS...

A application started before the Brexit still fall under eu law. The period from the application date till to the brexit cannot fall out. Thanks for advice mgb , that will be definately the fact for the court listing after appeal . Important : Had a phone call from my MP today morning, she received...

Hi Reynaldogr , I think you are confused .TA is people whose family members got Family permit or RC before 16 October 2012 will not be effected due to naturalization .We are all going to be end up in court battle and our family's going to be illegal after Brexit if decision not made before Brexit d...

A application started before the Brexit still fall under eu law. The period from the application date till to the brexit cannot fall out. Thanks for advice mgb , that will be definately the fact for the court listing after appeal . Important : Had a phone call from my MP today morning, she received...

Hello everyone , thanks for updating . I think Ron121 case is different and he is coverd by TA 2012 rules so ours case is different because of post October 2012 rules and only we got chance to fight after Lounes successful . I don't think there are much people similar to our cases because most peop...

Hi all .update I contact my MP regarding refused my PR .My local MP explain to HO about Lounes case .after 3 weeks we got respond from them .because the give right to appeal and I have no choice so I appeal it to court .any way the ho write back to my Mp . Mr xxx application was refused 9 November ...

Hi chaosconrol ,thanks for updating and information .yes good job we have to let them know . Over the different people different answers best way is by writing letter or e-mail so I am trying to find somebody who can write properly because of my poor English. I read here in this forum some send e-m...

Take them to the court, but you have already done that I suppose. After Lounes case judgement, it is irrelevant that your spouse has become British. Their decision is wrong. Hi romarmar, Any decision in your case? I'm in the same situation. Just wanted to know if your appeal was successful/ BR

Hi chaosconrol ,thanks for updating and information .yes good job we have to let them know . Over the different people different answers best way is by writing letter or e-mail so I am trying to find somebody who can write properly because of my poor English. I read here in this forum some send e-m...

Hello everyone , It looks like even Ron121 is covered is covered by TA and they resused his PR .If he had residence card or family permit in UK before 16 October 2012 then he is covered by TA no need to wait Lounes judgement implementation his situation is different than people after October 2012 s...

Hi there I am non eea famil member married with eu citizen. I got my 5 years resident permit at 27-11-2012, my wife’s bulgarian and British (dual citizenship) she got British citizen at October 2014. After 5 years( my eea family member resident permit finished) I directly filled Permanent Residance...

Hi i applied for Permanent residence after 5 year of marriage date .june 2017 / November 2017 I got refuse .secretary of state pointed out that my wife was naturalised as British citizens on may 2013 and asserts tha an EEA national is a national of an EEA state who is not also a British citizens Hi...