The Ruiz Zambrano opinion covers three questions. Question 3 is: (3) Must Articles 12 [EC], 17 [EC] and 18 [EC], in conjunction with the provisions of Articles 21, 24 and 34 of the Charter of Fundamental Rights, be interpreted as meaning that the right of a minor child who is a national of a Member ...
Do you have any news on the case involving an Article (3) 2 family member? I have an 'other family member' in exactly the same position. She was granted a Family permit by the UK, but refused on renewal. We are going through the appeal process now.
