Unfortunately, your family need permanent residence cards within 18 months so that they can apply for naturalisation. Otherwise, they are dependent on Surinder Singh rights surviving Brexit, and this looks increasingly unlikely. It seems that there aren't enough EU nationals dependent on Surinder S...

Well, they're not in accord with the currently established law, based on Eind, which is still listed in the Home Office guide on relevant case law!

Richard, do you have a link for me to a web site that shows this?

Great reply, thanks. They can all get stuffed. I'm not playing con games on behalf of governments, nor throwing money down a bottomless pit. We have discussed this as a family. They want us to leave, then we will. Had enough. Will appeal on principle though, and it will give us enough time to have a...

Well, I'm getting no help from guru's on this forum and I suspect I know why....because you all know that the changes made by the UK in Dec 2016 (LOL a couple of weeks before our 5 years was complete, ain't that a laugh), are in fact legal . Applied retrospectively too....also no advice from anyone ...

Guys, URGENT, any advice please on the following aspects of this merged thread:

1. EEA(PR) refused-Eind ignored, retroactively applying Dec 2016 changes

2. exercising treaty rights question about looking for work

3. absences query for a separate application for EEA2(PR)

Yes, I am also very interested in your experience. Can I ask, did you represent yourself? Can you explain in a little more detail what we can expect as we have to appeal now within 2 weeks. If they lose do they have to pay all your legal fees? Thanks. *MODS: PLEASE DO NOT MERGE THIS WITH MY ALREADY ...

Could you change the heading of this topic please as I urgently need the information on every query I have. Please change it to: EEA(PR) refused-Eind ignored, retroactively applying Dec 2016 changes, exercising treaty rights question about looking for work. Thank you Actually please change it to: E...

Could you change the heading of this topic please as I urgently need the information on every query I have.

Please change it to:
EEA(PR) refused-Eind ignored, retroactively applying Dec 2016 changes, exercising treaty rights question about looking for work.

Thank you

If you insist on merging every topic I have a question about could you please amend the title to include all the queries I have. That would help as some people might have had some experience and able to respond because its not hidden under a topic that is not relevant.Thanks

Anyone have advice on how to appeal an EEA PR decision (or an appeal in general for that matter). Did you represent yourself or lawyer up? Is the tribunal's decision final and no further chance of appeal? If you have no money is there legal aid? If you have no money to leave or split the family up w...

Does looking for work qualify as exercising treaty rights, regardless of whether this is carried out through job centre, or on one's own?

And if so, what constitutes evidence...print outs of every application made over 5 years? How many is sufficient. Anyone got any experience with this?

Thanks

Please stop merging these posts. This is becoming really confusing. The 'PR refusal' post has nothing to do with the 'Absences' post. IT IS NOT THE SAME APPLICATION! . An application has not even been submitted for the 'Absences' case. The absences post had nothing to do with the 9 months waiting po...

Well, well...our Surinder Singh application has been refused and Eind case law completely ignored. They are retroactively applying their Dec 2016 changes, with the result that we stand no chance because we cannot go back in time. How can anyone trust this government to do the right thing? Unbelievab...

Received the refusal letter today. Surinder Singh route and they completely ignored Eind case law. It says: "You have not provided sufficient evidence to demonstrate the your sponsor was a qualified person as a worker, self employed person, self sufficient, etc from xx/xx 2012 when your residence ca...

Risk of being asked to leave- if you already have permanent resident status, etc. and obtain the required documentation, maintain residence- approximately the same as the risk of Australia or Canada forcing all permanent residents to leave. In other words- around 0%. JAJ, I'm afraid you don't seem ...

Everything you've said is interesting but only really serves to deflect and distract...in my view. And quite frankly, googling 'time immemorial" is completely meaningless to the discussion. Please re-read my posts. The UK is breaking the law. Please research Surinder Singh, and its application accor...

And please, do us all a favour, and read SS law as applied in the EU. How can people abuse the law if they follow it. If they don't follow it, sure, kick them out BUT you can't kick people out just because you don't like the law, YOUR own law the law you agreed to as a member of the EU.

What was its original purpose according to you? How could it have been abused if it was according to EU law. Fair enough the UK doesn't like following EU law so it is brexiting. I have no problem with that but even and especially if you are a government you must follow the law to which you have sign...

ok ,lets try add some detail, maybe I'll get a better response. 2011 BC and non-EU dependants exercise Treaty Rights in EU country. child starts 1st year. 2012 Parents move to UK while child completes 1st year. Spouse submits EEA2 application and RC granted. Full disclosure in spouses's application ...

Yes, Rooibos, you are right- its a false sense of security...being lulled into waiting for a post brexit heaven. Both sides have the capacity to become complete demons, so for those that can, get your affairs in order in time. Don't trust any of them. You only need to see how HO are manipulating Sur...

Post by secret.simon » Fri Sep 08, 2017 6:47 pm greatscott wrote: ↑Fri Sep 08, 2017 5:56 pm Can we therefore assume absence over 6 months in a year for students is therefore acceptable? Please keep your questions in your thread, as your child's specific circumstances (being the child of a person re...

Other important reasons, such as pregnancy and childbirth, serious illness, study or vocational training Can we therefore assume absence over 6 months in a year for students is therefore acceptable? Anyone on this forum had experience in submitting absence for purpose of study, and being successful?

Obie, if you are around, would appreciate your thoughts. I don't hold you to any comments you have made. All I am interested in is to be able to make an informed decision on what our next step could be. Thanks. Obie, if you are around, would appreciate your thoughts. I don't hold you to any comment...

Regarding the fact that the regulation 9 amendments 2016 act in contrast to EU law, I did intend to write a cover letter citing case law and EU law but found people who had had their applications denied for doing this. The official reason being they must have used their legal knowledge to circumven...

by Obie » Sun Jan 29, 2012 11:50 pm Well i believe Regulation 492/2011 might be in play, provided this dependant is your direct descendant, is going to the memberstate in which you were a migrant worker, where he studied when you were a migrant worker or self-enployed person,to complete his or her ...