...beyond those required under the directive is a bit disingenuous... I would say illegal... On what grounds? Any clown can provide a "lease" and "letter from Landlord". It is possibly to fake these documents Granted PRTB letters can not be a ground to refuse an application, but they are useful, al...

1. A recent Tax certificate as proof of employment despite providing an employment contract and payslips; anyway the spouse has since requested for one and is on the way from the revenue office. That might be one way of proving that one is employed, but it is not mandatory and can be proved by othe...

The Commission Guidelines have also stated that the Authorities are entitled to ask for this stuff Could you provide a reference for this perhaps? NExt time, do your own research There seems to be alot of protesting about obtaining relatively simply set of documents. WHat is wrong, got something to...

Thanks a lot for that, article 38 in particular there makes things clearer. So no registration is required whatsoever for 90 days, but from what I can gather after that time you need to either have a job or show that you can support yourself without becoming a burden on social services - how much s...

Walrus....thanks for advice... This was one of the thong advised by one of my friend too..... I was Living together so far so I did not bother for direct debit but now the account is going to be open. I want to have the court orders too but what if she agree this on mutely decide sepration.. Great,...

Yes, and all of this is complied with if you properly read the Application form and the list of documents required. I'm not sure I understand. To me, it would appear that the authorities are requesting or demanding documentation in excess of those specified in the directive. Explain. They are not T...

Isn't that hypocritical of him to have sent out a refusal and intention to Recommend a deportation to the then minister fro justice when he has Already make such mistake knownly that the immigrant was never Imprisons and all the pages of his passport is full of residency stamp, you Name it, 1 month...

Hi many thanks for your reply however I do have a few questions. One his wife is not legal in Britian she is currently in America with their daughter. Coming to Ireland , under EU law History in Britain is irrelevant. Just prove that there is a family and there is a base. They have not currently ap...

25 is an absolute joke ! This is just pure bureaucracy . People paying tax and working hard are are having there life played with and their interests delayed . Some people living here since a young age (like me , since the age of 10) face serious problems because of this (i have to pay higher colle...

Hi, I hope one of the Mods can advise here.... I got approval for Irish citizenship last year and I am planning to relocate to Dubai next year... Does revocation of naturalization certs really exist? I mean can they found out if a person is out of the country and revoke his citizenship?? I know the...

If you can't comply with reasonable conditions of EU law (ie actually be coming here with a job and not notions of "Job searching" in a State that is making thousands redundant )and live here without resorting to State Welfare , they EU law free movement rights were never suppose to apply to such p...

You are married, you have automatic guardianship rights. I would suggest going to family law court and obtaining a court order regarding the right for access to the child and joint custody (probably might not get the latter) Why? Section 13 (Directive 2004 / 38 EC) also refers to retaining rights if...

Just to bump this thread instead of starting my own, does anyone know what the 'period of time' the OP mentions is exactly - i.e. how long a British citizen has to live with his non-EU spouse in Ireland before they could settle permanently in the UK and be treated as exercising treaty rights in the...

Hi there, thanks for your email. Well the changes have not gone though as of yet. Here is a petition against any planned changes. I hope the changes do not go through or are delayed. WHAT....THE POOR CANT HAVE A FAMILY AND BE HAPPY NOW!!!!! Basically is what they are saying. https://submissions.epe...

Please when you send your errand men out please be very careful and do never threatened us with prosecution again otherwise be prepared to be sack when you come up with fake prosecution for ego's displays. Why were you threatened with prosecution? What we you accused of? What basis were they proven...

Recital 14 (14) The supporting documents required by the competent authorities for the issuing of a registration certificate or of a residence card should be comprehensively specified in order to avoid divergent administrative practices or interpretations constituting an undue obstacle to the exerc...

god help us and stop this unjustice happening here, people waiting five years for basic human right r not getting their right this is abuse of immigrants ,and this is not up to the standards of eu. :cry: What a load of nonsense. Self serving rubbish. First of all, there is absolutely nothing in Hum...

It appears to me that, you're arguing the subject matter of promisory extopell, which can be proved and argued on the basis of..... (1) statement of a public officer (which represent the goverment says) (2) Based on documentation evidence to interprete right. You don't meet the criteria for a promi...

Hi everyone, My name is Ms Moritz (Mauritian national) and I have been living in Dublin, Ireland, since the 18th of Sept 2005 on a student visa till I got married to a Slovak national after 2 years. "After 2 years" , you married in 2007,so I made the application for a Stamp 4 EUFAM GNIB card on the...

Please when you send your errand men out please be very careful and do never threatened us with prosecution again otherwise be prepared to be sack when you come up with fake prosecution for ego's displays. Why were you threatened with prosecution? What we you accused of? What basis were they proven...

Why was he refused? Thanks for your reply. He was refused due to the Relationship History. I think they didn't believe that the relationship is genuine. You know, they are aware of this scam of marriage for convenience. If you've seen it in the television.Ours is real. we are married. I just come t...

You appear to be surprised that someone who is not competent is employed by INIS. I'm afraid there are numerous examples already mentioned on this board of how incompetent some of their staff are. Is the fianna fail government that employs them, had it been we have not studied law, he would gotten ...

Hi my son has been told by a Immigration Lawyer that he can look for work in another EU country and have his family join him however it was not clear if he needed a job before they could join him or if they can join him while he looks for work. Questions. One are they allowed to join him while he l...

Hi All, what are the requirements for a child of an Irish citizen ,to get Irish citizenship? I claimed Irish citizenship after my child was born( FBR ).Can my child Obtain any type of visa to live & work in Ireland, leading to citizenship through me? Or are they basically out of luck? Thanks in adv...

Hi All, I am inquiring on behalf of a friend who is married to a French citizen and both living in Ireland. She applied for Non EU residence permit as the spouse of an European in March 2012 and was sent an acknowledgement letter by INIS but they requested for further documents in relation to the a...