sushdmehta wrote:AFAIK, no country will cancel a passport (that has not been stolen or lost or without legal / statutory obligations) on a passport holder's request to do so when the passport holder continues to remain a citizen of that country!
noajthan, your wife lost her filipino citizenship when she became a UK citizen! So what worked for her (getting a passport, of the country she was no longer a citizen of, cancelled) doesn't necessarily mean that same course of action will work for those who do not lose their original citizenship upon acquiring British citizenship.
Understood - usual health warnings apply.
This is a largely uncharted area - although we are making progress, step by step.
Clearly the whole identity policy needs a legal challenge sooner or later.
fyi - the UK HO didn't accept my wife had lost her citizenship (a quirk of Philippine law).
The HO legal advice team then got it wrong; they misinterpreted & stated the Philippines Republic Act 'the wrong way' round to state their belief that she hadn't lost her citizenship by naturalising in UK.
Consequently it was HO who insisted the passport was cancelled, believing she was still a Philippine citizen.
They would not accept my correction of their flawed interpretation of R.A. 9225.
So they clearly believed cancelling a passport was a viable option.
I suggest 'canceling passport' as an option to explore; I am not saying it's possible in each country out there (as I do not know).
It took us a few days of stress & a day in the embassy to achieve it, plus some waiting time.
Compared to what some people face - returning to home countries to process long-winded paperwork it's a relatively small price to pay - so I'd say no harn in asking the embassy about cancellation, case by case.
If an embassy/country says no to cancellation then, yes, people will have to absorb the pain & inconvenience, also the cost & delays associated with such name/passport changes, (whether to be done via an embassy or else back in the original country).
As we are hearing this is sometimes not legally possible.
Some people may have to revoke their first citizenship to get round the road block, or else accept a British passport in the 'wrong name' (one not of their free choice).
Perhaps as more legal pain is felt it will help bring on the legal challenges this young & immature identity policy appears to require.