Question about interpretation of the BNA 1948
Posted: Mon Jan 19, 2026 6:38 pm
claim-citizenship-t217233.html
Hi Everyone,
About ten years ago I asked a question about my claim to citizenship (link above).
Quick background
My paternal grandparents where born in British India, pre-partition and they moved to East Africa pre-partition as well. They moved back and forth between Uganda and Kenya, but majority of the stay was in Kenya.
My dad was born in Uganda in 1956, and the same year they moved to Kenya, my dad's family moved to the UK in 1971, and my dad remained there until 1987. He married my mom in 1985 (Pakstani ILR). they both moved to LA in 1987, I was born in 1991 in Pakistan but lived in LA my entire life.
I applied for my first British passport in 2009 before my 18th, I was denied because my father couldn't transmit citizenship. This was a first for my family and entire family, all my cousin have dual. My parents aren't really the ones to push back to ask why. I planed on re-applying but life got in the way. In 2017 I did a SAR for my father, the HMPO said my father is a Citizen via 5(1) 1948 and 11(1).
IN 2024 I tried via 4L and was denied, the weight of the discussion was on the inaction of my parents failure to register me, story of my life, a day late and a dollar short.
In 2025, I took my wife and son to the UK and found out that my Grandparents had registered via 6(1) and 6(2), my grandmother registered 9 months after my father was born, grandfather unknown.
Now to the question,
The BNA 5(1) says that a child born to a father who is a cukc "otherwise by decent " then the child is a cukc by decent.
Hi Everyone,
About ten years ago I asked a question about my claim to citizenship (link above).
Quick background
My paternal grandparents where born in British India, pre-partition and they moved to East Africa pre-partition as well. They moved back and forth between Uganda and Kenya, but majority of the stay was in Kenya.
My dad was born in Uganda in 1956, and the same year they moved to Kenya, my dad's family moved to the UK in 1971, and my dad remained there until 1987. He married my mom in 1985 (Pakstani ILR). they both moved to LA in 1987, I was born in 1991 in Pakistan but lived in LA my entire life.
I applied for my first British passport in 2009 before my 18th, I was denied because my father couldn't transmit citizenship. This was a first for my family and entire family, all my cousin have dual. My parents aren't really the ones to push back to ask why. I planed on re-applying but life got in the way. In 2017 I did a SAR for my father, the HMPO said my father is a Citizen via 5(1) 1948 and 11(1).
IN 2024 I tried via 4L and was denied, the weight of the discussion was on the inaction of my parents failure to register me, story of my life, a day late and a dollar short.
In 2025, I took my wife and son to the UK and found out that my Grandparents had registered via 6(1) and 6(2), my grandmother registered 9 months after my father was born, grandfather unknown.
Now to the question,
The BNA 5(1) says that a child born to a father who is a cukc "otherwise by decent " then the child is a cukc by decent.