ESC

Click the "allow" button if you want to receive important news and updates from immigrationboards.com


Immigrationboards.com: Immigration, work visa and work permit discussion board

Welcome to immigrationboards.com!

Login Register Do not show

Unsuccessful PR application

Use this section for any queries concerning the EU Settlement Scheme, for applicants holding pre-settled and settled status.

Moderators: Casa, push, JAJ, ca.funke, Amber, zimba, vinny, Obie, EUsmileWEallsmile, batleykhan, meself2, geriatrix, John, ChetanOjha, archigabe

Locked
Grazia
Newly Registered
Posts: 26
Joined: Fri Nov 22, 2013 9:22 am

Unsuccessful PR application

Post by Grazia » Fri Nov 22, 2013 10:04 am

Hi there,

I’m EU citizen living in the UK since 2004. Recently I applied for certification of my PR status with 2 kids and non-EU husband.

I exercised treaty rights between 2004 and 2009 as:
Student (May 2004 - Sept 2005)
Self-sufficient person (supported by my husband) Oct 2005 – Apr 2006
I was out of the UK Apr 2006 – Sept 2006
Student (Oct 2006 – Sept 2010)

With my application I sent all the required documents such as utility bills, letters from estate agents/landlords, letters from university, bank accounts, CSI (Jan 2004-30 Apr 2009), registration certificate (issued in 2007 when I was a student).
We were all refused PR with the right to appeal. The reason for refusal was:
1. not sufficient number of transactions from bank account
2. lack of CSI for entire qualifying period

I want to add that at that time I was using two bank accounts, one in USA and one in the UK, copies of both statements for relevant period were attached and the situation explained in separate letter. From my UK account I was paying rent, internet and car insurance (DD). From the US account I was paying nursery fee (DD). My husband, working abroad at that time, was transferring money to my US account; I was withdrawing this money in cash machine and using cash for everyday life. It was nearly 10 years ago when card payments were not that popular and cash was the way to pay for shopping.

Could you please comment on this decision?

Many thanks in advance.

sheraz7
Respected Guru
Posts: 2509
Joined: Thu Jan 27, 2011 8:56 pm
Location: UK

Re: Unsuccessful PR application

Post by sheraz7 » Fri Nov 22, 2013 10:13 am

Grazia wrote:Hi there,

I’m EU citizen living in the UK since 2004. Recently I applied for certification of my PR status with 2 kids and non-EU husband.

I exercised treaty rights between 2004 and 2009 as:
Student (May 2004 - Sept 2005)
Self-sufficient person (supported by my husband) Oct 2005 – Apr 2006
I was out of the UK Apr 2006 – Sept 2006
Student (Oct 2006 – Sept 2010)

With my application I sent all the required documents such as utility bills, letters from estate agents/landlords, letters from university, bank accounts, CSI (Jan 2004-30 Apr 2009), registration certificate (issued in 2007 when I was a student).
We were all refused PR with the right to appeal. The reason for refusal was:
1. not sufficient number of transactions from bank account
2. lack of CSI for entire qualifying period

I want to add that at that time I was using two bank accounts, one in USA and one in the UK, copies of both statements for relevant period were attached and the situation explained in separate letter. From my UK account I was paying rent, internet and car insurance (DD). From the US account I was paying nursery fee (DD). My husband, working abroad at that time, was transferring money to my US account; I was withdrawing this money in cash machine and using cash for everyday life. It was nearly 10 years ago when card payments were not that popular and cash was the way to pay for shopping.

Could you please comment on this decision?

Many thanks in advance.
Since you already got Registration certificate on the basis of being student well before of 2011, therefore, your PR application should not be refused only on the grounds of CSI. You must ask for reconsideration of your case and yourself read about it at below:

Students issued with a registration certificate before 20 June 2011
If you were not asked to provide evidence of comprehensive sickness insurance, and later apply for permanent residence as a student, your application will not be refused solely on the grounds that there is no evidence of comprehensive sickness insurance on the date of decision.

For further guidance on the transitional arrangements for students who were issued with a registration certificate prior to 20 June 2011, please see Annex B of Chapter 6 of the European Casework Instructions (ECIs).
Please donot send PM. Write in open forum to facilitate others too.
REGARDS

vinny
Moderator
Posts: 32758
Joined: Tue Sep 25, 2007 7:58 pm

Post by vinny » Fri Nov 22, 2013 10:29 am

I don't understand what
1. not sufficient number of transactions from bank account
has got to do with PR?
This is not intended to be legal or professional advice in any jurisdiction. Please click on any given links for further information. Refer to the source of any quotes.
We do not inherit the Earth from our ancestors, we borrow it from our children.

Grazia
Newly Registered
Posts: 26
Joined: Fri Nov 22, 2013 9:22 am

Post by Grazia » Fri Nov 22, 2013 11:34 am

vinny wrote:I don't understand what
1. not sufficient number of transactions from bank account
has got to do with PR?
Here is exactly as they wrote in the letter:

“The bank account statements provided do not evidence sufficient transactions and balance amounts to substantiate your assertion that you are continually a self-sufficient person.
You have not provided evidence that you hold comprehensive sickness insurance in the UK. The evidence you provided ended on 30 April 2009. Any attendance during your study after this date was not covered.”

Qestion 1: Is there any defined balance or transactions required on your bank account to be self-sufficient person for PR purpose?
I simply were taking money from US account, paying in some into my UK account to cover direct debits and were using cash for everyday life.

Question 2: Do I have to show self-sufficiency while studying?

Obie
Moderator
Posts: 15156
Joined: Tue Apr 21, 2009 12:06 am
Location: UK/Ireland
Ireland

Post by Obie » Fri Nov 22, 2013 11:44 am

I can see the logic if a person is applying for Residence Card. The point is to ensure that a person is self sufficient.
In 2005-2006, OP will be required to show that she had sufficient resource not to be a burden on the UK resources. Simoly showing a medical insurance does not fulfil this requirement. Evidence of how you supported yourself is required. If her husband was supporting the family, evidence of this should have been adduced.

In the absence of that supporting document , residency will break in 2005-2006, therefore she resume lawful residence in 2006, the CSI covered 2004-2009. It should cover 2006 -2010 when you completed your studies, you should then show what you did from 2010-2011 to qualify.
Smooth seas do not make skilful sailors

Grazia
Newly Registered
Posts: 26
Joined: Fri Nov 22, 2013 9:22 am

Re: Unsuccessful PR application

Post by Grazia » Fri Nov 22, 2013 11:44 am

sheraz7 wrote:
Grazia wrote:Hi there,

I’m EU citizen living in the UK since 2004. Recently I applied for certification of my PR status with 2 kids and non-EU husband.

I exercised treaty rights between 2004 and 2009 as:
Student (May 2004 - Sept 2005)
Self-sufficient person (supported by my husband) Oct 2005 – Apr 2006
I was out of the UK Apr 2006 – Sept 2006
Student (Oct 2006 – Sept 2010)

With my application I sent all the required documents such as utility bills, letters from estate agents/landlords, letters from university, bank accounts, CSI (Jan 2004-30 Apr 2009), registration certificate (issued in 2007 when I was a student).
We were all refused PR with the right to appeal. The reason for refusal was:
1. not sufficient number of transactions from bank account
2. lack of CSI for entire qualifying period

I want to add that at that time I was using two bank accounts, one in USA and one in the UK, copies of both statements for relevant period were attached and the situation explained in separate letter. From my UK account I was paying rent, internet and car insurance (DD). From the US account I was paying nursery fee (DD). My husband, working abroad at that time, was transferring money to my US account; I was withdrawing this money in cash machine and using cash for everyday life. It was nearly 10 years ago when card payments were not that popular and cash was the way to pay for shopping.

Could you please comment on this decision?

Many thanks in advance.
Since you already got Registration certificate on the basis of being student well before of 2011, therefore, your PR application should not be refused only on the grounds of CSI. You must ask for reconsideration of your case and yourself read about it at below:

Students issued with a registration certificate before 20 June 2011
If you were not asked to provide evidence of comprehensive sickness insurance, and later apply for permanent residence as a student, your application will not be refused solely on the grounds that there is no evidence of comprehensive sickness insurance on the date of decision.

For further guidance on the transitional arrangements for students who were issued with a registration certificate prior to 20 June 2011, please see Annex B of Chapter 6 of the European Casework Instructions (ECIs).

Thanks Sheraz7 for your prompt reply. My understanding of the CSI is that I should be exempt from it for the period when I was a student because I applied for the registration certificate before 2001 while being a student. However, I attached the CSI to cover the period when I was self-sufficient person. Is my understanding correct?

Grazia
Newly Registered
Posts: 26
Joined: Fri Nov 22, 2013 9:22 am

Post by Grazia » Fri Nov 22, 2013 12:04 pm

Obie wrote:I can see the logic if a person is applying for Residence Card. The point is to ensure that a person is self sufficient.
In 2005-2006, OP will be required to show that she had sufficient resource not to be a burden on the UK resources. Simoly showing a medical insurance does not fulfil this requirement. Evidence of how you supported yourself is required. If her husband was supporting the family, evidence of this should have been adduced.

In the absence of that supporting document , residency will break in 2005-2006, therefore she resume lawful residence in 2006, the CSI covered 2004-2009. It should cover 2006 -2010 when you completed your studies, you should then show what you did from 2010-2011 to qualify.
Thanks Obie for your expertise but I don’t fully understand your point.
I applied for PR. For the self-sufficiency period I attached both bank statements:
1.the US bank account where my husband were regularly paying in money and I was withdrawing them in cash machine here in UK (evidence is on bank statements as cash withdrawals with postcode where that happened)
2.the UK bank account into which I was paying in some of this money I withdrew
I was not getting any benefits during the self-sufficiency period. Is that all not sufficient that I was self-sufficient?

Davmck70
Member
Posts: 161
Joined: Thu Jun 20, 2013 5:36 pm

Re: Unsuccessful PR application

Post by Davmck70 » Fri Nov 22, 2013 12:55 pm

My own approach to this matter is completely different. I will not question why they have decided to decline the application fully understanding that UKBA decisions are based on discretion at the service of individual case worker. I would rather look for evidences to back my claims up at the tribunal and also look for errors that have been made in making the decision. In as much as i love to advice on this particular situation, I am still learning more about the CSI and student applicants and thus can not say much at the mooment.
I am certain you will win this case from all perspective

Davmck70
Member
Posts: 161
Joined: Thu Jun 20, 2013 5:36 pm

Re: Unsuccessful PR application

Post by Davmck70 » Fri Nov 22, 2013 1:07 pm

Grazia wrote: I exercised treaty rights between 2004 and 2009 as:
Student (May 2004 - Sept 2005)
Self-sufficient person (supported by my husband) Oct 2005 – Apr 2006
I was out of the UK Apr 2006 – Sept 2006
Student (Oct 2006 – Sept 2010)
Can you give a timeline of when you applied and also when it was declined by HO?

Grazia
Newly Registered
Posts: 26
Joined: Fri Nov 22, 2013 9:22 am

Re: Unsuccessful PR application

Post by Grazia » Fri Nov 22, 2013 1:33 pm

Davmck70 wrote:
Grazia wrote: I exercised treaty rights between 2004 and 2009 as:
Student (May 2004 - Sept 2005)
Self-sufficient person (supported by my husband) Oct 2005 – Apr 2006
I was out of the UK Apr 2006 – Sept 2006
Student (Oct 2006 – Sept 2010)
Can you give a timeline of when you applied and also when it was declined by HO?
Thanks Davmck70 for your comment. I applied mid June 2013 and got the decision letter 24 September 2013. I appealed against the decission within 10 working days and will be going for the hearing on 20 January 2014. Please advise on the hearing process as I don't know what to expect. Will they decide and inform me about the decission on the same day?

There is one more thing in all this case that worries me the most. UKBA didn't return my husband's passport and send him rather aggresive letter to immediately leave the country.
Do they have the right to do that? How can we get his passport back?
Many thanks for your help.

Davmck70
Member
Posts: 161
Joined: Thu Jun 20, 2013 5:36 pm

Post by Davmck70 » Fri Nov 22, 2013 1:59 pm

Grazia,
I would suppose you have chosen the Oral hearing instead of paper. You have enough time between now and hearing date to prepare. My advice would be to use the website below to check which hearing is close to you and you can witness one to have an understanding of the way it works. Its a very relaxed environment to hear from both sides what transpired and also look for a way to amicably resolve issues in accordance to the governing laws and policies.
http://www.tribunals.gov.uk/Immigration ... tlists.htm

They will not return your hubby's passport as standard procedure which is a bit frustrating but not to worry, they have no right under the law to ask him to leave the country so kindly ignore the letter. You will win this case

Grazia
Newly Registered
Posts: 26
Joined: Fri Nov 22, 2013 9:22 am

Post by Grazia » Fri Nov 22, 2013 2:13 pm

Davmck70 wrote:Grazia,
I would suppose you have chosen the Oral hearing instead of paper. You have enough time between now and hearing date to prepare. My advice would be to use the website below to check which hearing is close to you and you can witness one to have an understanding of the way it works. Its a very relaxed environment to hear from both sides what transpired and also look for a way to amicably resolve issues in accordance to the governing laws and policies.
http://www.tribunals.gov.uk/Immigration ... tlists.htm

They will not return your hubby's passport as standard procedure which is a bit frustrating but not to worry, they have no right under the law to ask him to leave the country so kindly ignore the letter. You will win this case
Thanks Davmck70 for your help. Will let you know the outcome after the hearing.
One more question, how long it takes to know about the decission after the hearing? Will they inform me immediately the same day? Thanks again.

Davmck70
Member
Posts: 161
Joined: Thu Jun 20, 2013 5:36 pm

Post by Davmck70 » Fri Nov 22, 2013 2:16 pm

Most times, the judge will want to make a decision on the same day unless there is any further disagreements which need clarified. If not, you will receive the decision via post after a maximum of "14 days" (not actual but from experience).

Grazia
Newly Registered
Posts: 26
Joined: Fri Nov 22, 2013 9:22 am

Re:

Post by Grazia » Fri Jan 31, 2014 2:49 pm

Davmck70 wrote:Most times, the judge will want to make a decision on the same day unless there is any further disagreements which need clarified. If not, you will receive the decision via post after a maximum of "14 days" (not actual but from experience).
Hi Davmck70,
Hurray! We have got the decission letters in which the judge upheld our appeal and we'll be also returned court fees.
However, the letter doesn't say what should I do next. Will I be automatically issued with PR as a separate document as I'm EU citizen (obviously if HOBA doen't appeal against court ruling) or I will have to fill-in some forms and send my passport?
What with my husband's PR (he is non-EU and HOBA has been keeping his passport). How long it can take until he gets his passport back with PR?

EUsmileWEallsmile
Moderator
Posts: 6019
Joined: Fri Oct 07, 2011 7:22 pm

Re: Unsuccessful PR application

Post by EUsmileWEallsmile » Fri Jan 31, 2014 9:26 pm

Contact UKBA and ask them to comply with the judgement.

Grazia
Newly Registered
Posts: 26
Joined: Fri Nov 22, 2013 9:22 am

Re: Unsuccessful PR application

Post by Grazia » Wed Feb 05, 2014 5:13 pm

EUsmileWEallsmile wrote:Contact UKBA and ask them to comply with the judgement.
Unfortunately this "hurray!" didn't last long. Today I was blown by the letter from 1st tier tribunal that Home Secretary applied for permission to appeal. It was a shock especially that during my appeal hearing HO representative didn't ask me even one question.
Please advise what should I expect next.
Q1. How long it can take before we are called for higher tribunal hearing?
Q2. Will the procedure be similar to our previous appeal, I mean HS will have to prepare grounds of appeal and we will know it prior to hearing or not?
Q3. Will I have to pay any court fee towards this appeal for example if HS appeal will be allowed?
Q4. As our appeal was allowed because we satisfied the HS refusal reason, the HS ground of appeal can be something new or HS things the judge was wrong?
I know some of these questions look weird but I'm trying to understand the process and be well-informed and prepared.
Your advice is much appreciated.

Locked
cron