Extension of the Workers Registration Scheme 2009 Unlawful

[claudia81]

Hi everybody here. I'm looking for expert. But is so difficult for me to find one. Could anyone here tell me what connection has domestic law with someone civil case?
I have a problem with WRS ( extension of WRS was unlawful but what legal force this has?

Do we all have to wait till June to all our cases will be submitted?
I don't understand why someone must to wait more time for their turn. Thousands EU migrants suffer because of WRS. How many tragedies behind only God knows. It's awful how this government acting. Don't you think?

[claudia81]

Hi
Is anybody here who could anwer to me? I will be very grateful. Do You have any experts? or maybe moderator of this page could help? Thanks in advance

[claudia81]

Hi
Anyody hear anything about new update? There is almost not possible to find this information in internet. It looks like a big joke. Here is case tracker

Case Tracker for Civil Appeals
Summary Case Details for 20151796
Case
Reference: C3/2015/1796

Title: Gubeladze v The Secretary of State for Work and Pensions

Type: Appeal

Appeal / Application:
from the order of The Upper Tribunal (Administrative Appeals Chamber)
Upper Tribunal (Administrative Appeals Chamber) dated 30-Jan-15
Hearing Status: Hearing Vacated - estimated length (in hours): 10:00

Venue: London

Constitution:
Not assigned
Not assigned
Not assigned

Case results:
Track Your Case:
Current Status: Awaiting a hearing - see Hearing Status

Tracking Information:
22-Oct-15: Case passed to List Office
22-Oct-15: Letter sent to applicant/solicitor to request bundles and/or documents
05-Oct-15: Application allowed on paper by Lord/Lady Justice
29-Sep-15: Application referred to Lord/Lady Justice
21-Jul-15: Bundle corrections were approved
09-Jul-15: Letter sent to applicant/solicitor requesting correction of bundles

Last Updated: 20-Jun-17
Look on last date almost 2 years for correction bundles?

thousands people are waiting for outcome and they do everything to delayed as it possible. That's should not be called justice. It's a shame

[Befudled_Bloke_2017]

UPDATE: Hearing Status: Fixed on 18-Oct-17 - estimated length (in hours): 10:00

- -----
Case Reference: C3/2015/1796

Title: Gubeladze v The Secretary of State for Work and Pensions

Type: Appeal

Appeal / Application:
from the order of The Upper Tribunal (Administrative Appeals Chamber)
Upper Tribunal (Administrative Appeals Chamber) dated 30-Jan-15
Hearing Status: Fixed on 18-Oct-17 - estimated length (in hours): 10:00

Venue: London

Constitution:
Not assigned
Not assigned
Not assigned

Case results:
Track Your Case:
Current Status: Awaiting a hearing - see Hearing Status

Tracking Information:
22-Oct-15: Case passed to List Office
22-Oct-15: Letter sent to applicant/solicitor to request bundles and/or documents
05-Oct-15: Application allowed on paper by Lord/Lady Justice
29-Sep-15: Application referred to Lord/Lady Justice
21-Jul-15: Bundle corrections were approved
09-Jul-15: Letter sent to applicant/solicitor requesting correction of bundles

Last Updated: 13-Jul-17
- -----

[Xter27]

Hi everyone,

I am really struggling to find any information relating to the proceedings of the Oct 18 hearing. That's if it wasn't cancelled again. Does anybody have any information to share?

http://casetracker.justice.gov.uk/getDe ... d=20151796 The case tracker is not up to date.

Thanks in advance.

[Obie]

Judgement is out tomorrow. Good luck to everyone waiting.

[Obie]

Extension of WRS ruled unlawful and disproportionate by Court of Appeal.

The Secretary of State for Work and Pensions v Gubeladze [2017] EWCA Civ 1751 (07 November 2017)

[Xter27]

Hi Obie,

Thanks so much for a speedy update, I was look forward to this news.

My main question is - can the SSWP appeal the ruling to The Supreme Court?

Also, this may sound silly, but I'm not 100% about this one - I came to the UK in 2009, but didn't register until 2011. Does the ruling essentially mean that those 2 years spent in the UK now qualify for PR (provided I meet other requirements of course)?

Thanks in advance.

[may1975]

I think whole WRS is just unfair. why someone not able to use periods between 2004 and 2009 because of lack of WRS?

[may1975]

Does all eu countries requires WRS till 2009?

[vinny]

Worker Registration Scheme extension unlawful, Court of Appeal confirms > The Secretary of State for Work and Pensions v Gubeladze [2017] EWCA Civ 1751 (07 November 2017)

[claudia81]

Hi good people do U know what is the final response about this case? What tribunal said? Thanks

[claudia81]

There is only this

Case results:
Refused on 07-Nov-17

is it mean bad for all of us? Thanks in advance

[vinny]

Supreme Court finds UK breached residence rights of hundreds of thousands of EU citizens > Secretary of State for Work and Pensions v Gubeladze [2019] UKSC 31 (19 June 2019)

New Judgment: Secretary of State for Work and Pensions v Gubeladze [2019] UKSC 31

[Obie]

One can only hope that the Home Office will not start issuing compensation to the children of A8 nationals in the UK, who were born here but they were refused passport and in some cases, some had their passports revoked on the basis that their parents were not registered under the scheme after 2009. Some were refused citizenship, some were forced to register their children, which as a matter of law, was clearly unlawful.