Damax wrote: ↑Thu Feb 20, 2020 9:11 pm
I have following objections on my brother's case. I am the sponsor and it was second time.
Biomatrics on 28th January
Decesion date 11th February
How to address this point? espacially last part of this statement
You are claiming that you are dependent upon your EEA Sponsor. As evidence of this you have received money transfer remittance from your sponsor naming you as the beneficiary. These are dated between January 2018 and January 2020. This limited amount of evidence in isolation does not prove that you are financially dependent on your sponsor or that any funds you have used to meet your essential living needs. You have not provided sufficient evidence regarding your own financial situation. Therefore, this department cannot sufficiently establish your dependency, either wholly or partially, upon your EEA sponsor because you are unable to establish your financial support from the EEA national to meet your essential needs.
This time this was new objection from ECO,
Furthermore, you have failed to provide sufficient evidence which proves that you reside in a property provided to you by your Sponsor and that you reside there with him. It is noted that the evidence you have provided is recent and that your Sponsor appears to have resided outside of Pakistan for a considerable amount of time. Therefore, I cannot be satisfied that you are part of your sponsor's household as claimed.
This time this was new objection too from ECO,
You state that your Sponsor sends you £ 200.00 per month. You have not provided sufficient information as to his own personal circumstances, for example, any immediate family who are dependent on him in xyz country, his financial responsibilities and commitments and his financial status. Furthermore, there is no evidence to suggest that your sponsor intends to stay in the UK upon arrival and continue to support you as required. On that basis, you do not meet the requirements of Regulation 8 (2) (b) and your application is refused. I therefore refuse your EEA Family Permit apPplication because | am not satisfied that you meet all the requirements of Regulation 12 (see ECGS EUN2.23) of the Immigration (European Economic Area) Regulations 2016.
Hi Damax,
It seems you have applied on the basis that the Sponsor is residing in Pakistan with the dependent?
If this route wasn't already difficult, it is even more difficult to apply on the basis that the dependant is part of the sponsors "household" and that you both intend to migrate to the United Kingdom.
I would the think the amount of evidence required to prove the motive is considerable such as;
1.Deeds for the House or Tenancy Agreement in the Sponsors name
2. Considerable savings to establish travel costs to the UK aswell as setting up home, furniture and the possibility to survive without a job until you secure one.
3. Job offer in the UK
4. Dependants circumstances in Pakistan, including his income (from Sponsor and/or any other sources) and his expenditure.
They also note that some of the evidence you have seems to point that Sponsor has been living outside of Pakistan whilst you are claiming that he lives together with his brother there?
I don't think they have a valid point in terms of Money Transfers not being enough as two years IS enough.
I would suggest you have until the end of this Year(2020) for the Sponsor to establish himself in the UK, continue to send money to dependent, get a job with income of more than £1300 per month net, do not claim benefits etc.
Make sure you send money from your account and into his account using a remittance company such as Transferwise or PayPal etc.
Hope this helps
All the Best
