swintooh, sorry to hear about suspending your research, I'm sure that I'm not only 1 person who read your statistics as some very helpfully in our situation.
Anyway, thanks for your good job made for us.
ESC
Welcome to immigrationboards.com!
Moderators: Casa, John, ChetanOjha, archigabe, CR001, push, JAJ, ca.funke, Amber, zimba, vinny, Obie, EUsmileWEallsmile, batleykhan, meself2, geriatrix
swintooh, sorry to hear about suspending your research, I'm sure that I'm not only 1 person who read your statistics as some very helpfully in our situation.
Robin, not to worry, I can continue to track that 22331500 to 22331999 batch daily as long as a forum member's case is in that somewhere as "awaiting decision". Otherwise I can occassionally track progress by weekly posts. I got a job that I'm starting soon so amount of free time I have on my hands will be greatly reduced.
That's not the right reference. It's probably just the letter reference, unless the reference system changed from what it was in June 2017.RobinCzWa wrote: ↑Fri Nov 17, 2017 11:47 pmI applied 19/10 and my Case ID is not recognised, but on acknowledge letter in top right corner (below HO adress) I get "Our Ref" number - it looks like Z112xxxx. If I take off first letter and put only these 7 numbers left then system recognise me and show that my status is Awaiting a decision.
I'm not 100% sure is it correct way, but it works (hope so that in this situation it shows my status, not some other person)
Ignore the other "Our Ref" number...Case Reference Number: 012345678
Regarding Applicant: Full name Country of Birth Date of Birth
It means what it says, your application will be handed to a caseworker when they become available, and they will make a decision with all the facts/ checks presented to them.
Hi mate i am silently following all the updates and I can appretiate the time and effort you put in to keep us informed.swintooh wrote: ↑Fri Nov 17, 2017 11:41 pm1 application status have changed from "awaiting decision" to "decided" over 1 working day.swintooh wrote: ↑Thu Nov 16, 2017 6:00 pm4 application status have changed from "awaiting decision" to "decided" over 1 working day.swintooh wrote: ↑Thu Nov 16, 2017 11:41 amRange 22331500 to 22331999 - applications made around 9-Jun-2017, acknowledged around 19-Jun-2017.
1 application status have changed from "awaiting decision" to "decided" over 1 working day.
211/281 are decided (75.1%)
69/281 are awaiting decision (24.5%)
1/281 is open (0.4%)
215/281 are decided (76.5%)
65/281 are awaiting decision (23.1%)
1/281 is open (0.4%)
216/281 are decided (76.9%)
64/281 are awaiting decision (22.7%)
1/281 is open (0.4%)
I'm suspending this research as JUSTMEHERE was the only person who asked me to continue and his/her status have just changed to decided.
I know what is official version, and my Case number what I get by email and biometric letter doesn't work (is not recognised). It's 229069xxswintooh wrote: ↑Sat Nov 18, 2017 12:47 amThat's not the right reference. It's probably just the letter reference, unless the reference system changed from what it was in June 2017.
When you get your biometric request letter the body of the letter states:Ignore the other "Our Ref" number...Case Reference Number: 012345678
Regarding Applicant: Full name Country of Birth Date of Birth
That 012345678 is the number you enter in the online checker. Try full number or one without the leading zero - 12345678.
Yes, you are not the only one waiting for the letter (after status change to decided).HarryC wrote: ↑Sat Nov 18, 2017 12:14 pmHi guys
My British citizenship application is now decided. I cant tell when the status changed because the date is no longer showing on the status site.
It went off long ago.
However its now decided. I didnt know when the application status changed to decided. So i called homeoffice and asked them about a date as i need to understand when my 10 days be over for approval letter. They told me it was decided on 7th November but i am yet to receive the letter. Has anyone else been in the same situation. My 10 working days will end on 21st November but its getting a bit frustrating.
Thanks
Thanks for the response. Its a shame that they ask us to pay such high fees and yet they can’t send it via first class postage.swintooh wrote: ↑Sat Nov 18, 2017 12:42 pmYes, you are not the only one waiting for the letter (after status change to decided).HarryC wrote: ↑Sat Nov 18, 2017 12:14 pmHi guys
My British citizenship application is now decided. I cant tell when the status changed because the date is no longer showing on the status site.
It went off long ago.
However its now decided. I didnt know when the application status changed to decided. So i called homeoffice and asked them about a date as i need to understand when my 10 days be over for approval letter. They told me it was decided on 7th November but i am yet to receive the letter. Has anyone else been in the same situation. My 10 working days will end on 21st November but its getting a bit frustrating.
Thanks
How they deal with each applications conclusion seems to be different. Some caseworkers must upload the status updates quicker than others and request the printed letter quicker, perhaps there's a backlog in the issue of decision letters, some people get letter before status is updated and some get status updated before letter and a delay, this is a human process so it won't be perfect.swintooh wrote: ↑Sat Nov 18, 2017 12:42 pmYes, you are not the only one waiting for the letter (after status change to decided).HarryC wrote: ↑Sat Nov 18, 2017 12:14 pmHi guys
My British citizenship application is now decided. I cant tell when the status changed because the date is no longer showing on the status site.
It went off long ago.
However its now decided. I didnt know when the application status changed to decided. So i called homeoffice and asked them about a date as i need to understand when my 10 days be over for approval letter. They told me it was decided on 7th November but i am yet to receive the letter. Has anyone else been in the same situation. My 10 working days will end on 21st November but its getting a bit frustrating.
Thanks
And here lies the problem. It can be made very good if not perfect - it is just a process meaning a set of defined tasks with known outcomes done in certain order.mrgs1 wrote: ↑Sat Nov 18, 2017 4:41 pmHow they deal with each applications conclusion seems to be different. Some caseworkers must upload the status updates quicker than others and request the printed letter quicker, perhaps there's a backlog in the issue of decision letters, some people get letter before status is updated and some get status updated before letter and a delay, this is a human process so it won't be perfect.
swintooh wrote: ↑Sat Nov 18, 2017 6:52 pmThe online checker is Beta, it may be improved or even withdrawn its an experiment, we are all in this trial. Perhaps they should return to just receiving a letter when it's decided?mrgs1 wrote: ↑Sat Nov 18, 2017 4:41 pmHow they deal with each applications conclusion seems to be different. Some caseworkers must upload the status updates quicker than others and request the printed letter quicker, perhaps there's a backlog in the issue of decision letters, some people get letter before status is updated and some get status updated before letter and a delay, this is a human process so it won't be perfect.
And here lies the problem. It can be made very good if not perfect - it is just a process meaning a set of defined tasks with known outcomes done in certain order.
What current mess is showing us is that Home Office cannot even plan and put a fairly simple process in place and than manage it appropriately. Crappy online checker, lack of consistency, processing applications not in date order, shockingly poor responses to enquiries and complete lack of transparency are there just to hide the incompetence of that institution.
By the way, I don't blame the poor and likely overworked case workers, but the Prime Minister Theresa May, Home Office Secretary Amber Rudd (plus their predecessors) and whoever they decided to put in charge of the caseworker team.
If anyone from Home Office would like to challenge my viewpoint, prove me wrong by getting industry standards about quality management and ISO9000 and ISO20000 certification where the nationality team and what they do is in scope.
Something that is bound to occur when the input (the applications and documentation) itself is inconsistent. One application may be that of a non-EEA applicant who has been salaried and goes through smoothly, another may be that of a non-EEA citizen married to a British citizen, but who has had issues in the past with working when he did not have the right to do so, yet another is that of the dependent adult child of an EEA citizen who has only acquired PR. If the cases are varied, one can hardly require consistency in their time-scales.
I would be very cautious about asking for this. I have worked in a few organisations which are ISO certified for processes (don't ask me which ISO certification) and the one thing that it did do was make the processes in the organisation tickbox exercises. If the user met all specific requirements, pass, else fail.
That of course may just slow the system down further if they have to keep updating the public facing system as well.
Quite a few probably the majority of July cases who posted have been decided online or have received letters. It's only been four months for some.MAS99 wrote: ↑Sat Nov 18, 2017 7:24 pmI also notice from Timeline topic that most cases that people re reporting are from May and June 17 . But on the same time, Aug and Sep-17 cases are also reported as decided .
SO I am not sure why July cases are taking that much time..This frustration will literally eat me. I mean if they can give us some real update, I am happy with that. They can take as much time as they want but just let us know that they are doing xxxxx now and it will take some more time
Fact that we don't know what is happening with our applications and you can't ask questions before 6 months, is just complete torture..
Sorry Simon, I don't agree with your explanation as it sounds like nothing more than excuses for HO incompetence. The naturalisation process and associated checks is relatively simple. I do process design and optimisation for living, believe you me what is being done here is simple.secret.simon wrote: ↑Sat Nov 18, 2017 7:35 pmSomething that is bound to occur when the input (the applications and documentation) itself is inconsistent. One application may be that of a non-EEA applicant who has been salaried and goes through smoothly, another may be that of a non-EEA citizen married to a British citizen, but who has had issues in the past with working when he did not have the right to do so, yet another is that of the dependent adult child of an EEA citizen who has only acquired PR. If the cases are varied, one can hardly require consistency in their time-scales.
I would be very cautious about asking for this. I have worked in a few organisations which are ISO certified for processes (don't ask me which ISO certification) and the one thing that it did do was make the processes in the organisation tickbox exercises. If the user met all specific requirements, pass, else fail.
That approach is fine in the EEA Route, indeed that is how it works in the main. But the citizenship process (and non-EEA immigration) has many aspects where appropriate discretion can and ought to be exercised by the caseworkers. Getting them ISO certified may speed up the process, but it will almost certainly lead to a tick-box approach which will cause more applications to fail.
I would rather a slower approach that analyses individual cases in detail, than a quicker system that is more error-prone and/or more demanding and exacting.
That of course may just slow the system down further if they have to keep updating the public facing system as well.
Besides, assume that they have requested for data from the HMRC and ACPO and they are waiting for that. Would it improve your mood any knowing that your case is stuck waiting for other government departments to respond? What if it kicks off a chain (HMRC data shows inconsistencies that requires contacting DWP and Companies House)?
There are so many variables and imponderables in the naturalisation process that expecting consistency is, in my option, foolish.
For the record, I do not work for the Home Office.
As an aside, MAS99, delighted to see that you have decided to continue to help out on these forums.
I apllied at 19 October and my Case Id still is not recognised. I checked 600 Id arround my number - 100 over and 500 below - results are really strange for me.SAM143 wrote: ↑Sun Nov 19, 2017 9:41 pmHi!
i just applied for my naturalization beginning of this month and have done my biomatric 1st week of this moth but case ID still not traceable on GOV web page.
please could someone let me know why this is not recognized or face same situation.
thanks in advance