@Obie we had a good discussion yesterday. there was idea to submit the sworn Affidavit by EU citizen, but one of the barrister not recommend this.. his point was ATM whatever you will provide they will see them with Fraudulent document lens As they are already not accepting what you provided so bet...

@Obie we had a good discussion yesterday. there was idea to submit the sworn Affidavit by EU citizen, but one of the barrister not recommend this.. his point was ATM whatever you will provide they will see them with Fraudulent document lens As they are already not accepting what you provided so bett...

Exactly that's what I mean. we find out very Odd/strange after comparing with FOI.. @griffith : My solicitor request FOI.. and In FOI there is one letter Recommendation Refusal .. they can investigate as long as they want.. I believe temp permission is your right if case is delaying from their side,...

Thanks @Alixlboy your words mean a lot bro.. :) Yesterday I met solicitor and review FOI and Refusal letter together.. I sort out FOI Index page in date order.. there are lots of strange things we found.. For example I submit application on 12/09/2018 and on 13/09/2018 Next day clerk recommend to re...

Thanks @kupuser I read all your post and your case history.. you gave nice advice.. @Alixlboy : they ignore her medical history of 2 different gps, her medical tests report of matter hospital, dentists and social welfare letter which she recieved by personally visiting social office by hand, her gym...

@Obie : would you please tell me what are my rights?? was married and issued stamp4EUfam, get divorced, apply retention application, 5 year visa expire, currently on temp stamp... and now they Revoked my Expired permissions, and tell me my marriage was shame marriage..

@Obie In first Para: they are saying she wasn't exercising her EU treaty right so that's why refused (whereas she was working before, between and after divorce, she was also medical insured, 15K in joint account) Honestly to me it sounds little weird.. second Para: documents are fake.. how fake call...

Below are word to word of letter.. Based on the information available, the Minister is of the opinion that the EU citizen may not have been excising their rights through employment, self employment, the pursuit of a course of study, involuntary employment or the possession of the sufficient resource...

Thanks @kupuser so means affidavit will not help.. may I ask how you sort this issue then??

Thanks @griffith : so you are saying i should expect another letter from minister stating why Polish authorities believe she is living in Poland not Ireland?? I'm not sure they tell the reason in those cases.. should I ask my solicitor to ask for reason why they think she wasn't in Ireland?? Yes mar...

@Obie do you think thats the case/Issue??

If I assume if thats the case then do I fell in chencholliah case??

Sorry Admins.. I believe Question fell into both categories..

If she was out of country that means I should fell into chenchooliah case.. if not then in Retention.. Bother topics were created by me..

Kind Regards,

@Obie : solicitor said if we get her statement under oath, then we can put strong appeal.. and if still they refused then we will go for judicial review. Hope this answer 'Can she provide an affidavit or statement to counteract that.' !!

may I ask what information EU countries can share??

@griffith : yes she was employed in Poland before Ireland.. do you think this is linked to decision??

Thanks @Obie for reply.. she was residing in Ireland, that's how I was able to provide each and every document where her name was mentioned.. they mentioned Polish embassy told them she was living in poland from 2014 to 2018.. 500 pages file, solicitor words they are drawing every asian with same br...

Yes 21 Days time they gave me.. I lost faith on DOJ, like what else document they were expecting??

Hi all, today I'm so dishearten after 16 months I got refusal letter for my Retention application. can't believe this, as she was in Ireland doing job and exercising her rights. On same letter they accept she was working in 2014, 2017,2018 and also said she wasn't exercising her rights.. below were ...

Hi all, today I'm so dishearten after 16 months I got refusal letter for my Retention application. can't believe this, as she was in Ireland doing job and exercising her rights. On same letter they accept she was working in 2014, 2017,2018 and also said she wasn't exercising her rights.. below were ...

I applied FOI October end 2019. after some days received letter please forward passport photocopy then solicitor forward that copy on 22 Nov. then they sent letter stating 'you will received FOI decision before 23 December' they mentioned the date themselves and guess what no decision no communicati...

Hi all, I am looking for some information about critical skill employment permit. Can anyone tell while in Ireland when you apply for critical skill employment permit, you need to submit just your degree or all the mark sheets?? Background: I'm living in Ireland from almost 10 years.. 8 years out of...

@griffith : I applied retention application 2018 sep and still waiting for decision. As my stamp4 was going to expired in 2019Oct so they send 4 months temporary stamp.. visa never revoke or anything, I believe it was pretty straight forward case. I believe temporary 9month stamp is not for everyone.

The minister is also writing to those with retention application, who he is minded to refuse, not all retention cases. Only those that do not meet the requirements of the regulations, because for example the EU citizen had left the state before a divorce commenced. Thanks @Obie for clarification. I...

Retention cases are delayed because of the chencholiah judgement. The immigration is sending out letters and this is what the letter says. """ The position in your clients immigration case is that his case is impacted by the ruling of the European court of justice in the chencholiah case. Your clie...

Thanks @azee81 : my eufam4 wasn't revoked.. do we have any clear lines or details from department. that which application fell in that category??

I have applied retention of rights in 2018 Sep.. not sure decision of my case is delay because of that case OR for any other reasons.. should I expect letter from department that my case fell under chenchooliah case OR not..