Grounds for EEA Family Permit refusal

[a.s.b.o]

Hello,

I want to ask for an advice regarding the ground for our appeal.

We submitted an appeal against a decision not to issue my grandparent with a FP to come to UK. Both my parents (my dependent family members) and I (Irish national) reside in UK. We solely relied on EEA legislation (section 7) to demonstrate him to be my dependent family member. We did not claim breach of human rights and I want to ask you if we should have (and will have to in the court)?!

We claimed that since my mother is my dependent family member and she is a registered carer for my disabled grand-parent, this qualifies him as a dependent family member too. I am now seeing concerned with this causal dependency. Can you please share your view on this one? He resides in my property, his pension is insufficient to pay all his medical bills and I pay them. Additionally, he cannot walk, is Spam dependent (24h/day) and requires assistance with medication / care. He also develops initial signs of dementia.

Thank you very much

[Wanderer]

How can someone be a registered carer for someone in another country?

[a.s.b.o]

How can someone be a registered carer for someone in another country?

My mother was a registered carer for him since 2012 until she arrived in UK two weeks ago. I presume that I can now re-register myself (an EEA national) as his carer but await that UKBA will treat this as being made to derive dependence.

Please advise on whether human rights are applicable grounds for an appeal.

Thank you

[a.s.b.o]

anyone?

just to reiterate the key question - is subsequential dependence (i.e. a grandparent is dependent on his/her child, who in turn, is dependent on EEA national) considered dependence for purposes of EEA movement?

Thank you very much

[Wanderer]

anyone?

just to reiterate the key question - is subsequential dependence (i.e. a grandparent is dependent on his/her child, who in turn, is dependent on EEA national) considered dependence for purposes of EEA movement?

Thank you very much

Can't see it myself, good luck with it.

[a.s.b.o]

anyone?

just to reiterate the key question - is subsequential dependence (i.e. a grandparent is dependent on his/her child, who in turn, is dependent on EEA national) considered dependence for purposes of EEA movement?

Thank you very much

Can't see it myself, good luck with it.

Hi Wanderer,

can you please elaborate?