EUspouse82 wrote:walrusgumble wrote:EUspouse82 wrote:IrishTom wrote:How does this failed asylum seeker have a PPS number?
Why was an illegal/failed asylum seeker allowed marry?
Why was he not deported with haste once his asylum claims were rejected?
Pertinent questions.
Are you for real? Do you know his immigration history?
Are you having laugh? Why was wasn't he deported in haste? What do you mean by that exactly? Have you ever heard of term 'Due process' ? and hello he is married to an Irish citizen.
It seems this forum is been infiltrated by lovey...and by the way..how are your family members doing in Canada/US/ Australia/ England etc etc ?
The moral of the story...cop on!
lovey? your assuming that his family in canada etc are illegal or have not entered fair n squarely.he might be a plank but the history of monife's husband is accurate,just the way he says it, is the problem.your look at your own country on how it deals with illegals before ranting "lovey"
I am not ranting Walrus. I assume he is Irish based on his username, and it is quite convenient for Irish people to overstay their visas in other countries e.g. US, Australia, Canada, NZ etc and by way of public policy be asking/begging for clemency on behalf of Irish (( undocumented)) which is a technical terminology for a person who is an economic asylum seeker . Ireland is currently hoping that her citizens emmigrate ( which they have done in abundance) to other countries so they can balance the sheets.
Before you say I should look at my country (assuming you have a clue where I am from), maybe you should critically access your country's attitude towards immigrants. It takes an average of 3 years to get a decision on citizenship applications, your immigration department is so inept, lacks cohesion, embarrases themselves on a constant basis and disgracefully cannot formulate policies without copying their hated neighbors (UK).
I would honestly advice you to stop editorialising and get a grip,you hate immigration into your country and you have persistently shown this through your posts, stop hyper-ventillating and get real.
Ireland is only exising as an economy because you are in the EU and due to the numerous mechanisms attached therein, immigration is one of them . You cannot have your cake and eat it!..
You are ranting an raving, when you raise comments with no relevancy to the topic. You also are quick, like others, (maybe its the fact that your through ID is temporarily hidden) to make comments that may have no grounds or proof. Its only a small proportion of Irish Citizens abroad that have illegal status (remember, Irish have a huge diaspora) It will be said again and again, what another country does with its foreign citizen's (including the illegal Irish, which I am sure there are plenty of other nationalities) There is absolutely no point bringing it up, as it does nothing for your case.
You assumed because he is Irish, he will likely have relations etc that are illegal in another country. That is what you said. Again, it has nothing to do
with your case. Irish are not the only ones! Just remember, when the Irish did campaign in America in the 1980-1990's, on immigration amensty, other nationalities also got the benefits, on the back of Irish Activities. But ask your self,why do the Irish actually get a more favorable ear from the politicians of another country? It has no relevancy to you.
Secondly, you are in a very strong case, so you have little to worry about. One way or another you will get your status renewed. It is just, that you don't, from the information give, appear to be entitled to PR due to wife's activities, which for some reason you won't disclose fully. With regard to the Zambrano - Deccie issue, I was referring to the EU Citizenship of your wife and not you, which might limit Zambrano, its not relevant at this time, so there is no point discussing it on this thread, therefore I won't discuss the nuances. (FOr the 4-5th time, your status is irrelevant)
Thirdly, if you are going to comment on my past posts, don't start misquoting me or assuming. My previous posts would show that I have no problem with Immigrants, regardless of who they are, coming to Ireland, so long as its done, at all times lawfully and by the correct procedure. It is my understanding, that the type of cases that I am critical with, are in absolutely in no way related to the facts of your case.
If you are going to point fingers, why did you leave your wife's country of origin, Britain, with its superior education system (well University wise) and better prospects for work?
Where is the evidence that the 3 year delay is an intentional to punish Irish people? If anything, most Irish Citizens would like to see a 3 year suspension of that policy until we improve things. The UK is probably the worse country to compare to Ireland regarding the delays on citizenship. They give citizenship out like confetti. Great. Yet you will hear them (even respectful commentators) complain that there is no real respect or loyalty or sense of Britishness (in any form) coming from them. Where in the legislation says, you have a right to citizenship simply by meeting the 5 years rule? Where is the rule that says that you can't have a annual quota in decisions (which is seems clearly that that it was they are doing). How do you know whether or is not a coherent plan ? You don't work in the Department and you don't know the real reasons for the delay. I am not saying, however, that the 3 year delay is right or fair.
More importantly, what has Irish Citizenship got to do with your case. You are looking for residency. Secondly I asked about how countries deal with ILLEGALS, so why bring up naturalization ? You can't get it if your illegal. Your fishing?
Evidence of the Irish hating the UK? Dislike of the military forces and some of their politicians does not mean a hatred of British people and their culture. Secondly, I would take with a pinch of salt, alot of what Irish people say about the British. You seem to only read and listen to History for the Simpletons (like most Irish Citizens and Foreign Commentators)
"I would honestly advice you to stop editorialising and get a grip,you hate immigration into your country and you have persistently shown this through your posts, stop hyper-ventillating and get real. "
I would honestly shut your mouth, learn to know the different between categories of immigration, learn to read what is actually said in posts and not what you like and learn what the law says (something very few people here can quote accurately , as oppose to what suits them) You would not dare say that in public or to my face, because it would be proven that you are basing it on false grounds , in a court of law. So why do it on the internet? You have a problem with knowing the difference between fair objective comment and the stuff that people like Irish Tom Rants out.
You have no made argument or response to either what I said or to what patty said, solely, along the lines of "oh you are wrong , Solvit says, my superiors say (despite having no expertise)
"Ireland is only exising as an economy because you are in the EU and due to the numerous mechanisms attached therein, immigration is one of them . You cannot have your cake and eat it!"
What has that got to do with your case? The decision to refuse you PR is correct under the law provided by the EU.
You will, in some for get further status and rightly so
. Many EU countries have began to question the validity of the Courts on Free movement issues, and their maybe signs that the European Courts may not take such a judicial activist approach to this part of the law in the future.
Immigration, is a tiny minute of a concern right now for most EU countries. Its the banking sector that is at concern, in Europe.
