EEA FAMILY PERMIT REFUSED FOR DEPENDENT PARENT

[Mirabell]

Dear All,

I wrote before about applying for EEA Family Permit for my mother. Unfortunately it got refused.

http://www.immigrationboards.com/viewto ... b9444f503e

Notice of Refusal:

You state that you are financially supported by your daughter and that you live in an apartment owned by your daughter and that you receive rental income from another apartment also owned by your daughter for your living costs. You stated income $320 a month. I note previously you applied as a general visitor and were refused on the 31.01.13. You stated you were self employed as a distributor, you made no mention in that application that you were financially dependant on your daughter or receive rental income. I also note intended visit for 6 moths and now one month later after being refused you state wish to settle in UK. I'm not satisfied that your now limited stated income is an accurate reflection of your current circumstance. The rental agreement has been issued 28.03.13, I'm not satisfied that this document has been issued solele for the purpose of this application.
You state that you live at ........You have provided a property document for this address in your daughter's name stating she purchased this apartment in 2006. I note that you provided a property ownership document for the 2nd flat again in your daughter's name that states this property was gifted to her on 06.03.10.
There is no evidence of rental income being received by you or into account since 2010 nor have you provided receipts to support this. I'm therefore not satisfied based on the evidence provided you are financially dependent on your daughter.

I refuse your EEA Family Permit because I'm not satisfied that you meet all the requirements of Regulation 12 of the Immigration (EEA) REgulations 2006.
___________________________________________________________
PLEASE HELP.

Mother scanned me receipts for getting rent from my property, is that sufficient enough for appeal? The ECO accepts the fact that mother lives in MY property rent free. Does this mere fact is enough to support our appeal.

Anxiously waiting for replies.

Much appreciated.

[Directive/2004/38/EC]

The ECO makes a whole bunch of other points. How correct are those?

[vinny]

Please continue in previous thread.