10020132 wrote: ↑Tue Jan 02, 2018 2:13 pm
So what I am trying to say is that I have created two full time jobs - cashier & general assistant as the same person can work in different roles especially when the roles are not specialised
Cashier
Employee A worked for 26 weeks @15 hours per week
Employee B worked for 19 weeks @15 hours per week
22 weeks @15 hours per week
Employee C worked for 24 weeks @ 15 hours per week
27 weeks @15 hours per week
General Assistant
Employee A worked for 26 weeks @15hours per week
Employee B worked for 19 weeks @5 hours per week
22 weeks @15 hours per week
Employee C worked for 24 weeks @15 hours per week
27 weeks @10 hours per week
It is an interesting attempt and on a very general level I think you can argue that one person working on two jobs should be ok as per the immigration rules.
A little confusing why you have split Employee B and C into 2 lines each..
But I think HO will be reluctant to agree with it because that opens up the possibility that people can hire one person for 24 months and claim they switched jobs after 12 months or were doing two jobs and so on - all of which is something they were trying to avoid with the April 2014 change.
You have two problems
1) There is no way this can be presented in the Job Creation table as it only asks for start and end dates and hourly salary. So, assuming that you haven't got separate payslips and split in the FPS, the split in hours between the jobs can't be calculated by the CW. If you have been somehow separating this in teh payslips and FPS submissions, then you can overcome that.
2) The second depends on the actual dates of the employees. Once you put in the actual dates and you can show that each job has 52 weeks of 30 hrs/week, then you have an argument. So, total up the hours of the three employees in each calendar week and if it totals 30 hrs, then you could have an argument. But, for example, if all three employees were working in the same week as Cashier, that week would have 45 hours for that job and HO will only take 30 hrs.
So, if you have some means of proving the hours worked for different jobs (payslips, FPS, timesheets, etc.) and you can split up the jobs (because you are pre - April 2014, you can have any number of jobs) so that each job does not exceed 30 hrs/week, you can give it a try.
But be prepared for HO refusing to reject such arguments and it may need to be decided by a court through a JR. I personally would not consider it worth it.
My comments are in no way meant to be advisory. I have no professional knowledge of immigration. These are based on my own experience, convictions and personal interpretation of publicly available information.