Tier 1 entrepreneur extension refused

[Knc003]

Hi All Members
I need help i came in 2014 , Sep on Tier 1 Entrepreneurs team 200k visa we applied last year november for extension i got refusal on july 2018 HO refuse on two reason investment bank statement and job issue they said your 2 jobs is not exist for 12 month . In your application you said 3 different tittle jobs.
Then we applied AR we explain actually is not three jobs is only 2 two full time jobs
A done 9 month full time
B done 8 month full time
C done 7 month full time
But C cover 3 month to complete A 9 month
After C cover 4 month to complete B 8 month
A start job aug 2015 till april 2016 then C start this job for 3 month full time. Means this 12 month job finish in july 2016
B start job Aug 2015 till March 2016 then C start this job in aug 2016 till oct 2016 this job is done for 12 month
C cover this both jobs in different time peroid not same time .
When my solicitor fill application they mention 3 jobs 9 month , 8 month , 7 month and 3 employment contract all full time.
After 30 days i got again refusal but in this refusal they awarded me 20 points for investment now they said we considered your first application 2 jobs is
Not exist HO give again chance for AR we applied again AR and we explain again is only 2 jobs like above example. In this month i got again refusal . Now please all member help me what can i do to go for fresh application or JR one more major fault is after first extension application when i applied in Nov 2017 no one is on pay roll now in july 2018 i give 2 full time job . Please all gurus and member help me i have only three days left to submit.

[uzair286]

Sorry to hear about ur refusal. You mentioned that one point is bank investment could you please explain about that.
Another Thing you need to contact with your accountant to procide you job creation letter, FPS and RTI. Hope that will work.

[Knc003]

Thanks for reply Sorry is typing error is business account bank statement was missing i send HO again now only job issue left we allready submit FPS , RTI HO accepted . They said again we consider your extension application
Thanks

[marcnath]

So if I get it right, you filled in the job table as three different jobs ?
What were the actual jobs that these employees were doing ?

[Knc003]

Yes we write in table 3 jobs
we already mention to HO if you read employees contract job description is almost same duties .
Office administrator
Operational manager
Office manager

[marcnath]

Yes we write in table 3 jobs
we already mention to HO if you read employees contract job description is almost same duties .
Office administrator
Operational manager
Office manager

Ok.

Unfortunately I think it is tough to justify that as two jobs.

Especially since you yourself stated it as three different jobs in your application form.

In the first place, you should have filled in the Job Tables as you explained in this post (and maybe in a separate letter to HO).

I don't like the two jobs of 12 month each rule, but that is the rule as it stands. You have, in my personal opinion, no chance on JR either.

You can try make a fresh application, this time showing it as only two jobs. You will have to show that the same person changed his job - the role, duties and so in Aug 2016. You should write a detailed reason why the Office administrator/manager job was no longer required after Aug 2016. You can then argue that since the operational manager role was still needed, you changed the job for this employee rather than hire a totally new person.

I am not very optimistic that would be accepted but that is about all you can try.

[Knc003]

Thanks for kind reply we tried to explain two time in AR they only consider from extension application.

[marcnath]

Thanks for kind reply we tried to explain two time in AR they only consider from extension application.

And they are correct in that - AR is not supposed to take new documents, evidence, information- only to consider errors that may have been made