Welcome to immigrationboards.com!
himal11 wrote: ↑Wed Jul 25, 2018 12:29 amDear Gurus and Members,
Tier 1 initial 50k applied after appeal right exhaust on August 2017
Refusal on June 2018 after interview
Admin review refused on 16 July 2018
Main refusal reasons:
1. Business is not credible based on interview notes.
2. Service contracts between July 14 2014 till JAN 2015 not included /no bank letter.
3. Market research.
Only market research withheld after admin review. No points awarded on the basis of geneuiness.o ly 10 points on maintenance.
50k in the bank for 3 months
2 service contracts between 2017-018
3.6 months recent business bank statement
4.Hmrc corporation tax letter
7.maintenance funds for 3 months
8. Main accounts and accountant letter
9 all docs as per requirment.
10. Cover letters
Could not include previous contracts dated before julh 14, 2014 and bank letter. They were with home office while i made first tier 1 application and were not returned. This was mentioned in the cover letter.
I did not include the copies .
However i mentioned those contracts during the interview.
My reasons for pursuing JR:
1. Irrationality and procedurial fairness not exercised as caseworker took negative assessment of my answers, faulty notes and did not provide opportunity to answer to fullest. Very narrow and rigid format used.
2. Based on assumptions from interview no flexibility policy exercised to ask for missing documents as yhey were mentioned during interview as well.
3. No questions asked about co tinous business activities during interview.
Pls advise how is the merit of the case towards JR as the inteview was used to deliberately formulate reasons for refusals not based on facts recorded or docs submitted but on their over the top assumptions.
Any similar situation and JR success pls share. Need your thoughts and replies to make right.
maig wrote: ↑Wed Aug 01, 2018 4:09 amHi
I have gone through the same, my second/fresh application was refused on interview & documents.
Applied for admin review: refused
Applied for pap: refused
Applied for permission to bring JR (papers): refused
Applied for permission to bring JR (oral hearing): permission granted
Now I received consent order from treasury solicitors, invite me to withdraw JR, in return respondent will reconsider my application within 3 months & pay me reasonable cost.