Child benefit over payment

[cgp247]

Hello guys I am new in this forum .I appreciate your advice.
My ILR was revoked in 2015 for TOEIC. Then I had to go through very hard time. After fighting approximately three years I won my case. Judge clearly mentioned he is fully satisfied with my interview and allowed my appeal under immigration rules.
I have two children and my child benefit was continued. In 2017 I received letter from Child benefit office stating that there is some over payment occurred because of the revocation. I explained the situation and request some time from them. Child benefit office allowed me 12months. After 12months they start writing to recover the over payment. I have sent them the copy of the judgement. They reply when the over payment occurred I didn’t had any lawful status. I appeal against this decision and my hearing was yesterday at magistrate court. Even there I found the judge is confused.
I explained to the judge after HO reinstated my visa my application for naturalisation allowed straightway and I am a British citizen now. The judge keep replying in that (TOEIC) judgement the judge didn’t mention anything about the time from 2015 to 2017 ( Revocation to judgement date).
So the judge from the magistrate court in not sure does this win (TOEIC 2017) means I was lawfully staying in this country.
The judge from magistrate court allowed me 21 days to explain this time period and send him further documents.
Please advise me on this matter .

[Londoner007]

Yes one advise - see a legal adviser who specialises in Welfare benefits

[cgp247]

Thanks for your advice. Actually I am looking for the paragraph which cover and indicate the winning the appeal means I was living in UK lawfully.
Even the judge asked me to show him the immigration rules which cover this period.

[Londoner007]

Perhaps you can get clarification from the judge that allowed your appeal and send that into DWP.

[cgp247]

Perhaps the judge is confuse him self. He was asking me to show him any immigration rules which cover the time period I was residing lawfully.

[Londoner007]

Judges are still human and make a lot of mistakes. That's why I advised you to seek specialist benefits representative.

[London20]

Hello guys I am new in this forum .I appreciate your advice.
My ILR was revoked in 2015 for TOEIC. Then I had to go through very hard time. After fighting approximately three years I won my case. Judge clearly mentioned he is fully satisfied with my interview and allowed my appeal under immigration rules.
I have two children and my child benefit was continued. In 2017 I received letter from Child benefit office stating that there is some over payment occurred because of the revocation. I explained the situation and request some time from them. Child benefit office allowed me 12months. After 12months they start writing to recover the over payment. I have sent them the copy of the judgement. They reply when the over payment occurred I didn’t had any lawful status. I appeal against this decision and my hearing was yesterday at magistrate court. Even there I found the judge is confused.
I explained to the judge after HO reinstated my visa my application for naturalisation allowed straightway and I am a British citizen now. The judge keep replying in that (TOEIC) judgement the judge didn’t mention anything about the time from 2015 to 2017 ( Revocation to judgement date).
So the judge from the magistrate court in not sure does this win (TOEIC 2017) means I was lawfully staying in this country.
The judge from magistrate court allowed me 21 days to explain this time period and send him further documents.
Please advise me on this matter .

Hi,could you tell as how did you sorted your toeic case,please ,many thanks

[London20]

Thanks for your advice. Actually I am looking for the paragraph which cover and indicate the winning the appeal means I was living in UK lawfully.
Even the judge asked me to show him the immigration rules which cover this period.

Please reply to me comment.share your solicitors name .thanks

[CR001]

Thanks for your advice. Actually I am looking for the paragraph which cover and indicate the winning the appeal means I was living in UK lawfully.
Even the judge asked me to show him the immigration rules which cover this period.

Please reply to me comment.share your solicitors name .thanks

Members are not permitted to post names and details of solicitors on the forum!!